FIC: Must Have Learned Them From A Million Stars [SG-1, Sam & Daniel, PG]

Apr 11, 2007 09:45

This fits into the Valentine 'verse, one of (at least) two stories that (will eventually) come before the Daniel/Vala/Cam arc, but unlike the stories already written, which fit necessarily together, this story can be read on its own. When I was working on this, I called it "the one about everything I know about Sam Carter".

Title: Must Have ( Read more... )

fic:stargate sg-1, fic:stargate sg-1:valentine 'verse

Leave a comment

synecdochic April 11 2007, 20:22:07 UTC
It doesn't feel like you at all -- or if it is, well, you and Sam overlap to a scary scary degree. Because this feels exactly like how I see Sam, this wonderfully round three-dimensional woman who's full of flaws and contradictions and confusions, and seriously, it's just note-perfect voice and tone.

And I totally disagree with you about "how Daniel sees Sam" not being in there. Because it totally is. You do the same thing I do when you're writing tight third person limited like this; you have your viewpoint character make observations about the other character's actions, and then whatever spin the vp character puts on it doesn't matter, because the reader's formed her own impression. I totally have a strong and solid sense of what Daniel's thinking about Sam right here; it's hard to put into words, but it's sort of this hopeless love thing, where he loves her and respects her but he can't articulate it and he's painfully aware of all sorts of regrets that they both carry. The two of them have such a weird level of connection; they get some things without even thinking about it, and totally miss other things that might be totally obvious to someone else.

It really is one of the best things you've ever written, hon; not just for what it says, not just for how it says it, but for the way that it is this perfect polished jewel of exactly-the-right-amountness; there is not an excess word, and everything that is there contributes to the overall impression rather than distracting from it. It's certainly one of the best character pieces I've ever read.

Reply

minervacat April 11 2007, 20:49:04 UTC
The two of them have such a weird level of connection; they get some things without even thinking about it, and totally miss other things that might be totally obvious to someone else.

*clappy* that's EXACTLY it, exactly how i saw them in this story, and even how i see them reflected in parts of "sun-bleached history" -- i wanted to write something that would inform their conversation toward the end of that, and i think (i hope!) i've succeeded. so yay, thank you for that validation (and for the technical explanation of what i'm doing, because i'm very clear that it's what i do, especially in tight third person, but i don't know that i could have verbalized it.)

and thank you, again. just. you know what i mean. *hands*

Reply

synecdochic April 12 2007, 01:08:10 UTC
*hands right back at you* Yes! Like that!

(and you are a very, very smart writer; you do things that are very right, and even if they're not conscious choice, you know how to listen to your story and your characters and take them in the right direction. it is a very, very valuable skill. how the hell do you not have a hundred comments on this story already? *flail*)

Reply

minervacat April 12 2007, 01:15:53 UTC
your rec just made me cry, d, and i mean that in the best possible way. thank you so, so much. *clings*

Reply

synecdochic April 12 2007, 01:27:26 UTC
Every word of it the God's honest truth! Hand to God, this story is head and shoulders above everything I've read in a really long time.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up