Sherlock's Mummy

Apr 08, 2011 03:22


So, the only reference to Sherlock and Mycroft's mum in the BBC series is

Mycroft:  And you know how it always upset Mummy
Sherlock: I upset her?  Me?  It wasn't me that upset her, Mycroft
John: N-no wait.  Mummy?  Who's Mummy?
Sherlock:  Mother.  Our Mother.  This is my brother, Mycroft.

To me, that sounds clearly past tense.  It could be short for "used to upset" or "had upset" or "continuously upset" [and I'm currently resisting to name off all the possibilities is grammar-speak :-P] ... But if it were present tense it would be,  "and you know how it always upsets Mummy."  And Sherlock would say, "It isn't me who upsets her, Mycroft"

Right?

Only, I just assumed from the get-go that Sherlock and Mycroft's mum was dead before this started.  (In fact, it even sounds to me like the terrible Christmas dinners are a thing of the past, though I wouldn't fight really hard about that one.)  And now everyone has a pet theory about her... wouldn't it be awesome if she were played by Judi Dench, etc.  and I'm wondering if I'm just crazy....

character: dr. john watson, version: bbc sherlock, character: sherlock holmes, character: mycroft holmes

Previous post Next post
Up