Not a good cause... just 'cause.

Jan 26, 2005 10:21

What's the best movie ending ever? Go over there and speak your mind ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

Comments 3

leech January 26 2005, 10:34:37 UTC
That author has no thesis; the whole article is a rambling, disconnected, series of whines.

Reply

meep January 26 2005, 11:26:16 UTC
Well, he does (too much "scheduled" or "pre-arranged" activities that encourage dabbling but no deep committment), but it's definitely not something I can get worked up over. It seems like an excuse to meander in his idea of the perfect liberal arts institution.

I don't see anything wrong with careerism amongst students... indeed, promoting intellectual play without any tether to the real world is not doing students a favor, if they leave college with no real skills and a bunch of debt. When all the students came from wealthy families, they could afford the luxury of wasting time or creating their own lit mags.

Heck, I think it's pretentious to think that one must be in a university setting, with scads of free time, to consider deeply of intellectual subjects. Heck, one can get that experience for free, in real life.

Reply

leech January 26 2005, 12:17:54 UTC
It seems like he's relying on a completely undefined notion of "purpose", which gives me the creeps. Does he think all students attend college for the same reason? Or that they should leave it with the same ambitions?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up