I would humbly suggest that two is a bit young for Star Wars, even "A New Hope". It's not so much the mild violence in that movie, but the threat and chance of a character you start to like and care about *potentially* getting hurt that can terrify a young one and give them nightmares, and it's that sort of threat that make the action scenes exciting to older audiences (the droids getting captured by jawas, the shooting scenes as our heros fight stormtroopers, the garbage disposal scene, etc.).
Then there's the graphic imagery of Luke's charred and dead parents, which only happen for a second, but it'll be a fast, scary and confusion second for a real young guy, opening all kinds of "I could lose my parents?!?" nightmares on top of things.
Jen always deferred to me on judging appropriateness for Iain when he was younger, and nearly always admitted that I had an unerring talent for thinking of the single scene that might scar or be age inappropriate ("Look! a boobie!" ;).
That's the answer I was looking for. I just wasn't sure and neither was Steph. Thank you. We'll wait till next year to introduce him to Banthas and the like.
I saw Return of the Jedi at the drive in, with my parents & my little brother (who, I think slept through most of it)... It came out in '83 & I was born in May of '79, but I'm pretty sure I wasn't that young, since, I think it was a double feature, with La Bamba (1987) being the second flick, so, who knows! Personally, I'd say, give it another year or two. No matter how innocent we may feel the movie(s) is(are), you wouldn't want a kid having nightmares over a film that you love.
I'm beginning to think you guys are right. This is something we're going to have to wait for. Maybe make it a movie night next year or two. BTW I can see how RoTJ and La Bamba can go so well together at a drive in. That's something else we should do next year. Steph and I went to the drive in once this year and we plan on doing it again next.
There's a drive in here in Toronto? Where? I used to love going to the drive in, but they closed down the last one in Montreal ages ago (& then left it vacant, with the screens falling apart & just looking decrepit. :(
Comments 18
I was born in 76.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Except for the Holiday Special, of course. The kid should be at least eight before he/she sees Chewbacca's dad have a noisy Wookie orgasm.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Then there's the graphic imagery of Luke's charred and dead parents, which only happen for a second, but it'll be a fast, scary and confusion second for a real young guy, opening all kinds of "I could lose my parents?!?" nightmares on top of things.
Jen always deferred to me on judging appropriateness for Iain when he was younger, and nearly always admitted that I had an unerring talent for thinking of the single scene that might scar or be age inappropriate ("Look! a boobie!" ;).
Reply
Reply
Personally, I'd say, give it another year or two. No matter how innocent we may feel the movie(s) is(are), you wouldn't want a kid having nightmares over a film that you love.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
(*shrug* I live in a world of glittery nail polish and Disney Princesses. I'd call this a win.)
Reply
Leave a comment