challenge 1; round 1: results

[redhour]

Unfortunately we must say by to the following this week:

by soulcanhope with -4 votes and


VOTER'S CHOICE:

by pinklemonade417 with +1 votes

MOD'S CHOICE:
no mod's choice.

VOTING TALLY if your number isn't listed, you've received no comments
01; + - = 0
02; + + - = +1 >> VOTER'S CHOICE
03; - - - - = -4 >> ELIMINATED
04; - - - = -3
05; + - - = -1
06; + - - - = -2
07; - = -1

COMMENTS
1:
- text is really fuzzy and her right leg is unnaturally red
+ I love the text and cropping!

2:
- image is rather blurry
+ The texture is lovely and it's colored very well.
+ nice coloring, brush fits nicely.

3:
- Her skin looks too smooth and it looks odd.
- mariska is too yellow, too dark.
- the coloring is a bit too much, it takes away from the pic of Mariska
- The colouring on her face makes her look too shiny and golden.

4:
- the picture is very pixelated and it doesn't look good, which is a shame since the stamp idea is very good.
- way too pixelated. the image isn't clear at all
- She's not very clear - oversharpened, maybe?

5:
- too much of an orange-yellowish tint
- the brush seems out of place
+ The colouring is calm and pleasing to the eye, and she's not too sharp, but sharp enough, and the brush fits well with the cropping of the icon =)

6:
- The text is oddly placed.
- the text doesn't fit well with the icon
- The font doesn't fit very well with the style of the icon
+ the colouring is subtle and pretty, and the text was done well

7:
- doesn't look like anything was done, too plain

If you have any questions, feel free to ask.

ex0h will be posting round 2