Henry's former partner on the PD, Eddie, shows up in town after years away. Not so coincidentally, the murderer of Eddie's brother has just turned up dead. And shortly after Eddie's arrival, Henry goes missing.
The story features Gus with a crush on Jules; Lassiter having feelings for Shawn; pivotal scenes in a diner, a church, and Henry's house. Also, Shawn sets Gus up on a blind date with a man, and there's an argument over the merits of Sesame Street vs. Fraggle Rock.
A Case of Redemption, by Andie O'Neill
Note: The end of the eighth chapter (as it appears on ff.net) says To Be Continued, but the chapter feels like the completion of the story, so I'm not listing this as a WIP.