Whodunit? 9/9

[marea67]

Whodunit? 9/9

By Marea67
About: Kevin, Scotty, the Walkers - in one way or another…
Rate: We’ll see per chapter, this one - G
Disclaimer: Brothers & Sisters doesn’t belong to me. Written with love, not for money.
Summary: This is an AU, based on B&S, anything can be different, nothing is as it may seem, and yet, …. (evil chuckle)

Comments

[anonymous]

I'll say something not nice, apologize first.

Personally I only accept two kinds of murderer:
1、Revenge. Some bad guys should be punished by law but somehow there's some abnormal situation like no evidence, bribe, etc;
2、Psychologically or mentally immature Murderer; like kids, mental patients,etc;

and I thought there isn't a single humann being can replace justice and basically no one can tell if the other one shoule be dead or not; Even Hitler deserves a trial; and if any grown-up still affected deeply by their parents, they should blame themselves first...so conclusion: William Walker maybe desevers to die but he don't desevers to be murdered.

Marea you really have wonderful writting skills, so I think you can write some awsome original fics, next time when there's a murderer in your fics, please don't named him "Scotty Wandell". I can help but ask "what's that guy to do with Scotty?" all the time. Scotty Wandell is just a ordinary people, he has his own little happiness and troubles, he may not have some extraordinary accomplishment, but he don't have to murderer someone and live with the negative feelings in his entire life. If you don't like him, please just ignore him, leave hime alone, please, I'm begging you.

I always thought AU means another background, character can be changed if it's necessary, but a murderer? seriously. Hey, but maybe I was wrong.

[marea67]

No harm done. You're entitled to your own opinion. :)

****

... and if any grown-up still affected deeply by their parents, they should blame themselves first...

That is where I disagree. The impact that parents have on their children, even grown up children, can be enormous. In an ideal world, they are our first teachers, they should be the ones we rely on, the ones to protect us from harm, the ones to guide us through life until we can take responsability of our selves.

Unfortunately, becoming a parent is usually easier than being a parent and sometimes our parents are our worst enemies. Not just in physical abuse, but also emotional abuse. And that abuse can range from destroying a child's sense of self-worth to smothering a child to death, over-protecting a child or just not allowing it to grow up.

Sometimes it's just hard to step away from years of abuse and indoctrine, especially if you cannnot recognize it as such or even realize that the relationship is unhealthy or not normal. And also because we've been told from a young age on to love our parents regardless, turning some parent-child relationships into some pretty sick relationships where the child feels the need to love/protect the parent, even if that parent is killing him/her.

The way your parents treat you when growing up, can affect your life until your dying day and even after they are long dead.

*****

I'll take your words even further. I don't accept murder at all. Revenge doesn't solve anything and only brings forth more bloodshed. "Psychologically or mentally immature Murderer" are people who cannot take responsibility (or limited responsibility) for their crime. This however doesn't make it a 'lesser' crime. It is still murder.

That said, murder happens around us, whether we like it or not. And honestly, as much as I believe that murder is wrong, regardless of the reason, if anyone would dare to hurt my kid, he/she will end up 6 feet under the ground and I'll dig the hole myself. Would my action be 'right'? No! But, hell, I'll do it anyway.

If you don't like him, please just ignore him, leave hime alone, please, I'm begging you.

I love Scotty very much. He's, after Kevin, my favorite character on the show and I have nothing but the highest respect for Luke Macfarlane, who's an outstanding actor. I think that he would be able to play Scotty as emotionally torn between two evils and trying to protect the man he loves and still make us feel sympathy for him.

I chose Scotty on purpose, because anyone can become a murderer if the right buttons are pushed.... Even Scotty.

[anonymous]

Apologize first, again.

I agree, some people just should not be parents, they treat their kids badly, they should go to hell; for the children, the affect is eternal, getting rid of that kind of parents is way more difficult than getting rid of any other people in the world;--that's why I said William Walker maybe deserves to die;
But I also believe a theory "people can't hurt you if you won't let them" makes sense partly; if children (grown-ups, except the psychologically and mentally immature ones) let their parents hurt them that much, they really should ask themsleves, why can't they do something to change that horrible situation; and when they can't endure their parents anymore, they should take their responsibility--that's why I said, they should blame themsleves first; and William Walker don't deserves to be murderered; William have done some bad things, but the others are not just victims;

Anyway, that's the differents between us which I can take it, if the fic is original, I might enjoy it; What really bothers me is the name of the murderer;

I read most of your B&S fics, I once thoght you like Scotty, but now I believe that you don't like him, you just like using him to set of how wonderful, cute, irresistable Kevin is; he's a useful tool, isn't he;

Making a character you love suffers is ok, makeing him become a murderer? How can you say you love him? Please stop the illusion, you don't like him, don't even mention love;

Hey, maybe we have different definition of love;

[marea67]

I'm sorry you feel that way, but it's your opinion and you're entitled to have it. I have a different one, to which I'm entitled.

I think it best to leave it at "agree that we disagree". :)