No cheating. That means clone accounts, tactical voting, etc.
Do not feel obligated to vote for an icon because you think you know who made it.
You will vote for two icons. One for lowest-quality and one for best overall. Crits are required for lowest-quality and optional for best overall.
Please use the following voting format:
Lowest Quality: ## - (Criticism here)
Best Overall: ## - (Criticism here; optional)
Other Criticisms ## - (optional)
Lowest count for one minus point, Best count for one positive point, other criticisms don't count for any points, but may help the icon-maker improve and can be very useful!
Examples of a good criticism: ## - The textures don't seem to match the icon ## - The icon is too oversatured
Examples of bad criticism: ## - I don't really like this fandom very much (umm... no one asked you, lol) ## - The icon doesn't seem to match the theme (I get to decide that, not you. lol.)