ROUND 09; [RESULTS] The Mirror
Originally, this round would eliminate five people; however, we had a tie for 5th place, and felt it would be unfair to break it - the campaigns of the two contestants had been so similar! Therefore, manga_battle has six finalists.
Sadly, this also means four people have to go...
Eliminations
(deceive)
... was eliminated with 20 points left.
(realised)
... was eliminated with 21 points left.
(nyaabo)
... was eliminated with 23 points left.
(fujitsubo)
... was eliminated with 24 points left.
To the eliminees - we're very sorry to see you all go, and hope you'll continue to participate in this contest by voting! Congratulations for making the top 10, and I hope you join the next challenge!
Finalists
Congratulations to the 6 of you for making it this far! The final round will be up shortly...
People's Choices
No banners, because we are lazy like that.
Best Overall
[Icon #08] (+13 favorite points)
Best Coloring
[Icon #08] (7 votes)
Best Cropping
[Icon #01] (9 votes)
Best Typography
[Icon #09] (10 votes)
Most Original
[Icon #04] (12 votes)
Mod note: We were both equally impressed on how well icon 8 did this round. Even though the icon didn't have any typography, it still won 12 out of the maximum 17 points (or 12 out of the 14 possible points if you remove the typography category). Kudos to you, Luke!
Battle Logs
A
Alicia Florence | Allen Walker
K
Kon Shinonome | Kureha Fujishima
L
Luke fone Fabre
M
Mukuro Rokudou
N
Naoji Ishizuki | Nana Oosaki
R
Rena Ryuuguu
W
Wolfram von Bielefeld
Point Standings for Round 09
OVERALL
#01 - +3
#02 - +12 {+2}
#03 - +7
#04 - +12 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+3}
#05 - +1
#06 - +7
#07 - +3
#08 - +13 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+5}
#09 - +7 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+1}
#10 - +13 {+4}
COLORING
#01 - 0
#02 - 1
#03 - 1
#04 - 3 {+1}
#05 - 1
#06 - 5 {+2}
#07 - 1
#08 - 7 {+3}
#09 - 1 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+1}
#10 - 6 {+2}
CROPPING
#01 - 9 {+3}
#02 - 0
#03 - 0
#04 - 2 {+1}
#05 - 0
#06 - 0
#07 - 4 {+1}
#08 - 4 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+2}
#09 - 0
#10 - 7 {+2}
TYPOGRAPHY
#01 - 4 {+2}
#02 - 3 - TIEBREAK RUNNER-UP - {+1}
#03 - 3
#04 - 3 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+2}
#05 - 0
#06 - 0
#07 - 3 - TIEBREAK RUNNER-UP - {+1}
#08 - 0
#09 - 10 {+3}
#10 - 0
ORIGINALITY
#01 - 3 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+2}
#02 - 1
#03 - 0
#04 - 12 {+3}
#05 - 0
#06 - 3 {+1}
#07 - 2 {+1}
#08 - 4 {+2}
#09 - 0
#10 - 1
link to voting table here;
Comment to this post if you'd like to see your critiques and the detailed favorite point log, stating your avatar and icon number(s). Some crits were very harsh, so make sure you can handle them! All crits are 100% anonymous, and crits will be screened - if you don't get comments e-mailed to you, leave your e-mail address here and I'll e-mail your crits instead.
Comments in this post are, as usual, screened. If you have any public comments to make, you can make an anonymous comment (under your avatar's name if you'd like), and if it's anonymous enough, I'll unscreen it. IP logging is on, so don't try to pass off as someone else! Alternatively, you can comment under your regular name and I'll recomment with your public message myself.
Sadly, this also means four people have to go...
Eliminations
(deceive)
... was eliminated with 20 points left.
(realised)
... was eliminated with 21 points left.
(nyaabo)
... was eliminated with 23 points left.
(fujitsubo)
... was eliminated with 24 points left.
To the eliminees - we're very sorry to see you all go, and hope you'll continue to participate in this contest by voting! Congratulations for making the top 10, and I hope you join the next challenge!
Finalists
Congratulations to the 6 of you for making it this far! The final round will be up shortly...
People's Choices
No banners, because we are lazy like that.
Best Overall
[Icon #08] (+13 favorite points)
Best Coloring
[Icon #08] (7 votes)
Best Cropping
[Icon #01] (9 votes)
Best Typography
[Icon #09] (10 votes)
Most Original
[Icon #04] (12 votes)
Mod note: We were both equally impressed on how well icon 8 did this round. Even though the icon didn't have any typography, it still won 12 out of the maximum 17 points (or 12 out of the 14 possible points if you remove the typography category). Kudos to you, Luke!
Battle Logs
A
Alicia Florence | Allen Walker
K
Kon Shinonome | Kureha Fujishima
L
Luke fone Fabre
M
Mukuro Rokudou
N
Naoji Ishizuki | Nana Oosaki
R
Rena Ryuuguu
W
Wolfram von Bielefeld
Point Standings for Round 09
OVERALL
#01 - +3
#02 - +12 {+2}
#03 - +7
#04 - +12 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+3}
#05 - +1
#06 - +7
#07 - +3
#08 - +13 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+5}
#09 - +7 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+1}
#10 - +13 {+4}
COLORING
#01 - 0
#02 - 1
#03 - 1
#04 - 3 {+1}
#05 - 1
#06 - 5 {+2}
#07 - 1
#08 - 7 {+3}
#09 - 1 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+1}
#10 - 6 {+2}
CROPPING
#01 - 9 {+3}
#02 - 0
#03 - 0
#04 - 2 {+1}
#05 - 0
#06 - 0
#07 - 4 {+1}
#08 - 4 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+2}
#09 - 0
#10 - 7 {+2}
TYPOGRAPHY
#01 - 4 {+2}
#02 - 3 - TIEBREAK RUNNER-UP - {+1}
#03 - 3
#04 - 3 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+2}
#05 - 0
#06 - 0
#07 - 3 - TIEBREAK RUNNER-UP - {+1}
#08 - 0
#09 - 10 {+3}
#10 - 0
ORIGINALITY
#01 - 3 - TIEBREAK WINNER - {+2}
#02 - 1
#03 - 0
#04 - 12 {+3}
#05 - 0
#06 - 3 {+1}
#07 - 2 {+1}
#08 - 4 {+2}
#09 - 0
#10 - 1
link to voting table here;
Comment to this post if you'd like to see your critiques and the detailed favorite point log, stating your avatar and icon number(s). Some crits were very harsh, so make sure you can handle them! All crits are 100% anonymous, and crits will be screened - if you don't get comments e-mailed to you, leave your e-mail address here and I'll e-mail your crits instead.
Comments in this post are, as usual, screened. If you have any public comments to make, you can make an anonymous comment (under your avatar's name if you'd like), and if it's anonymous enough, I'll unscreen it. IP logging is on, so don't try to pass off as someone else! Alternatively, you can comment under your regular name and I'll recomment with your public message myself.