Ooh! A topic!

Nov 23, 2005 11:48

Okay, have thought of a topic to alleviate boredom with Fanfic Discussion ( Read more... )

writing: fanfiction, fanfiction: hp, fanfiction: feedback

Leave a comment

photosinensis November 23 2005, 17:10:17 UTC
Get rid of the Buffy crossover in STNE. It was, in my opinion, the weakest part of the series.

Reply

jacyevans November 23 2005, 17:12:31 UTC
I second that. As much as I liked it as first, it seemed extremely out of place with everything else that was going on in the chapter.

Reply

yenesi November 24 2005, 05:47:34 UTC
me three or four or.... a little strange for me on that part, Buffy was straight from left field.

Reply

changes pippin23 November 23 2005, 17:55:21 UTC
That was exactly what I was going to bring up. I also think some of the stuff between the Master and Allegra sexually could be removed. We got the point about his dominance of her. It takes a lot to get me squirmy about fan fic. I always ended up skimming those sex scenes because they didn't add to the story. That was really the only area that seemed gratuitous. (And I am usually a big fan of gratuitous)

Thanks for sharing your baby with us. I know it's yours, but it takes a lot to go soliciting this kind of "what did you hate".

Reply

Re: changes hllangel November 23 2005, 18:14:38 UTC
I don't think the stuff about the master/allegra should be removed at all. it's because it's squicky and uncomfortable and perfunctory that they're so good. Allegra is someone who does everything for a purpose, even sex. The master is using it to turn her against herself and everything that she was before he actually materialized. It's the last area of her life that she has control over and he takes it. And of course re-establishes it by having an affair with Napoleon.

Lori, DO NOT CUT IT.

Reply

Re: changes madlori November 23 2005, 18:26:24 UTC
Um...SO not what I was referring to. That stuff is in HWTF, which I don't plan to touch. Just PoU.

Reply

Re: changes madlori November 23 2005, 18:27:53 UTC
Oops...didn't see what your comment was referring to. Never mind.

And no, I feel that the Master/Allegra sex is important for her character, and for his as well. I have no plans to change anything in HWTF...yet.

Reply

Re: changes hllangel November 23 2005, 18:45:27 UTC
Just replying to a comment...

I have to think about what needs to be rewritten in PoU. I haven't read it in a while.

Reply

Re: changes pippin23 November 23 2005, 20:47:56 UTC
Okay, I must have stated badly. I understand the importance of the interplay between the Master and Allegra. I agree that it is integral. I was only trying to say that there was a bit too much of it. That was all. It is unimportant now as Lori was only referring to PoU (Sorry I misunderstood) but I wanted to clarify my comments. It shouldn't be removed because it makes me uncomfortable. I just thought it should be scaled back because it made its point and seemed to be flogging the horse so to speak.

Reply

Re: changes madlori November 23 2005, 18:29:06 UTC
Unfortunately I do not have any current plans to rewrite STNE (though give me a few years and we'll see how I feel) but if I did, that crossover would be the Number One thing on the chopping block.

What was I thinking?

Reply

Re: changes photosinensis November 23 2005, 18:44:41 UTC
Eh, while Master/Allegra non-con squicks me, it's rather integral to her defection (however long it lasts). Besides, I kinda like the sick, twisted, Oedipal aspect of that storyline.

Reply

saucy_wench November 23 2005, 23:09:07 UTC
Hell yes.

Reply

lapsus_0_calami November 24 2005, 14:38:04 UTC
That's the only thing which I found odd. Let it go!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up