Lumos Lims - Round Four, Challenge Nine: Results

[427]

PROMPT.

VOTING.


ELIMINATED:


by darlingbones
# 03 [ -03 + 00 ] = -03


by apologizeg
# 04 [ -04 + 01 ] = -03


by pierhias
# 05 [ -02 + 01 ] = -01


VOTER'S CHOICE:


inamotelroom
You've earned a spot in the Final Challenge. Congratulations.


MOD'S CHOICE:

I will not be choosing a Mod's Choice this week.


POINTS

# 01 [ 00 + 01 ] = 01
# 02 [ -01 + 02 ] = 01
# 03 [ -03 + 00 ] = -03 [elim]
# 04 [ -04 + 01 ] = -03 [elim]
# 05 [ -02 + 01 ] = -01 [elim]
# 06 [ -01 + 06 ] = 05 [vc]


In the round, a "least favorite" vote received -1 points and a "favorite" vote received +1 points.

WORST VOTE COMMENTS

#02 - the text seems a bit messy, and the line in the middle just doesn't fit in.

#03 - The orange border is [not well executed] and makes the icon appear slapped together.
#03 - The orange at the top and bottom looks like it was slapped on, and doesn't really compliment the image. Perhaps if it had more texture to it, it would fit better?
#03 - icon seems to be thrown together quickly. The orange corners are kind of distracting.

#04 - [the crop is off putting, her head floats off the frame]
#04 - the icon is too dark and it makes her look red
#04 - Good cropping, but the coloring is a little dark, and Gina's face is over saturated
#04 - the crop is uncreative, a central crop would be much more striking if her head weren't cut off. The colouring is also unflattering with the intense yellow/orange on her skin. Good use of texture however.

#05 - There is too much contrast in the icon (the hair is too dark and the skin is beyond pale).
#05 - it looks oversharpened.

#06 - The coloring looks too orange. And the text is too big and distracting.

FAVORITE VOTE COMMENTS

#01 - Great b&w coloring and cropping.

#02 - 2 looms like the most care was put into designing it. The texture perfectly compliments the image.
#02 - adore the text, good coloring/texture choice

#04 - the lightness of the icon, which is mostly dark colors, is very eye catching. the icon is so simple but great :)

#05 - nice crop

#06 - This is just made of win. 1 comes in a close second for quality, IMO, but I think this one wins for composition, originality, and sheer rawr.
#06 - While the coloring is very red/orange, it fits the image, and the text is perfect!
#06 - the text fits perfectly with the picture, its just a brilliant compination.
#06 - great use of text, while the icon is overly orange it doesn't unflatter the subject (did that make sense?)
#06 - The text goes well with the icon and the coloring is beautiful!
#06 - Funny icon, and an awesome cropping!

MOD NOTE:
Congratulations to everyone who participated in this challenge! The next challenge will be up shortly.

{comments are not screened. | to leave a screened comment for the mods please go to the contact us post.}

YOUR FINAL THREE:
inamotelroom fahrenheit1993 pokecharm; Congrats! and Good Luck!