Round Four, CH07: Results

[427]

PROMPT.

VOTING.


ELIMINATED:


by caramelmilk_t
# 10 [ -08 + 00 ] = -08


VOTER'S CHOICE:


by fahrenheit1993
# 01 [ 00 + 04 ] = 04
Since byes are no longer allowed, you can no longer win a bye for winning voter's choice. However, congratulations on winning!


MOD'S CHOICE:


by inamotelroom
# 04
a) I like the coloring, 2) it's true, and iii) good compo and typography


POINTS

# 01 [ 00 + 04 ] = 04 [vc]
# 02 [ -01 + 00 ] = -01
# 03 [ 00 + 02 ] = 02
# 04 [ -01 + 03 ] = 02 [mc]
# 05 [ 00 + 01 ] = 01
# 06 [ 00 + 00 ] = 00
# 07 [ 00 + 02 ] = 02
# 08 [ -02 + 00 ] = -02
# 09 [ -01 + 01 ] = 00
# 10 [ -08 + 00 ] = -08 [elim]



WORST VOTE COMMENTS

#02 - The lighting and coloring has made him lose definition in his face, a lot more on his right side.

#04 - The color overlay is too strong and the text is too large and bold.

#08 - The skin has a plastified, very very blurry look. The text doesn't work well with the image. It doesn't add interest. The coloring is too green.
#08 - The cropping is too close, and we the text could be upside.

#09 - The orange and green coloring is too harsh, and obscures Draco's features a bit. [this could be a typo and a vote for 10, we aren't sure]

#10 - The text is too overpowering and doesn't blend in well. The coloring makes the icon look strange, and very unnatural.
#10 - the text doesn't match, and it's difficult to distinguish Malfoy. Also, the green and pink is a little overdone.
#10 - the colouring is really harsh and why is he so pink?
#10 - malfoy's face is too bright on the left side...all definition of nose, mouth, ear and jawline are lost.
#10 - The coloring you've used has really done a number on Draco's complexion, he's a little flat and green-tinged which leaves him looking a little like the undead. I like the typography but I feel that the neutral color matches his skin tone too well, leaving the icon with only three colors (two of which are a little clashy.)
#10 - the colouring is unnatural + unflattering
#10 - The colouring is poor, and the texts don't fit the image.
#10 - texture is over-powering, and colouring is too washed out/not contrasted enough

FAVORITE VOTE COMMENTS

#01 - Great coloring, esp. with the thought of how the image looked like before.
#01 - great central crop + soft colouring
#01 - The coloring is great, it adds life to the image. The textures used work well and are flattering.
#01 - Nice, simple cropping and coloring.

#03 - great use of image, good contrast of black and white.
#03 - nice cropping and the contrast & shadowing are perfect.

#04 - Nicely colored and nice use of text.
#04 - The text is creative, and the coloring is lovely.
#04 - Beautiful coloring and crop, the colous fit the icon as well.

#05 - The words fit with Draco's facial expression, and the cropping is good.

#07 - the crop and lighting are really doing something for me :)
#07 - I absolutely love the composition for this icon, the border mixed with the grainy texture makes it look like an old photograph and the crop/positioning of Draco with all the negative space gives a very empty and stark feel. It's very well done.

#09 - The colors work very well together, the cropping is excellent, and it's just a really nice icon.

MOD NOTE:
Congratulations to everyone who participated in this challenge! The next challenge will be up shortly.

{comments are not screened. | to leave a screened comment for the mods please go to the contact us post.}