Comments | lotr_community: Fairly Compromised by Zhie

zhie in lotr_community

Fairly Compromised by Zhie

Aug 16, 2010 02:34

Author:Zhie
Title:Fairly Compromised
Rating:PG
Theme: Two Sides to Everything
Elements:Is the choice of the peredhil unfair?
Beta:Lalaith_Raina
Author's Notes:Standalone; Bunniverse compatible. Uses three or four lines from The Silmarillion, which only briefly makes mention that there was a debate somewhat related to this topic, and what a few ( Read more... )

month: 2010 august, august, challenge: two sides, 2010

Comments 7

shirebound August 17 2010, 00:19:50 UTC

Ahhh, the terrible power of choice. This is well done; a most logical and far-reaching conversation.

dreamflower02 August 17 2010, 00:28:14 UTC

A good debate, turning over all the possibilities. The choice is a difficult one, to be sure, but as is pointed out, NOT having the choice is even more unfair.

blslarner August 17 2010, 00:33:31 UTC

Quite a spirited debate, and one in which the various sides each have merit. Well done!

kayleelupin August 17 2010, 04:30:22 UTC

A hard choice indeed! But at least they made the choice to GIVE them the choice!!

Well done!

Kaylee Arafinwiel

lindahoyland August 17 2010, 05:28:07 UTC

A very well written look at this complex argument.