Leave a comment

Comments 22

longmonologue April 4 2008, 14:55:00 UTC
This was so bittersweet yet so gorgeous - you could just feel the agony of being in love, and losing that love, pouring off this chapter. Absolutely fantastic!

Reply

lorannah April 4 2008, 23:25:03 UTC
Thank you so, so much. Bittersweet was my main key word for this chapter, so it means so much that the first comment even mentioned it. :D

Reply


such_heights April 4 2008, 15:03:22 UTC
“Did we love each other?” Ianto asked after a moment. “The diary doesn’t say.”

“I don’t know,” Jack replied honestly.

Oh my heart! That was such a beautiful, aching ending to this fantastic story. I loved that there was no magical solution to all of this, the way it ended leaving people a bit more broken and damaged - oh, Tosh - and the way that John dealt with Adam and then just left was very nicely handled.

I don't really know what else to say, other than I've enjoyed this immensely, was delighted to see you post this today, and thanks so much for the ride!

Reply

lorannah April 4 2008, 23:26:25 UTC
Thank you. :D

I'm glad you liked John's ending. I had the hardest time deciding what to do with him.

Reply


samantharichter April 4 2008, 19:11:03 UTC
Yay, you managed to post this in time! Go, you!

Absolutely great chapter! Great ending! I'll go and rec this to my flist now. ;)

Reply

lorannah April 4 2008, 23:27:06 UTC
Thank you.

:D

Reply


pike2 April 4 2008, 20:08:08 UTC
This was just so good!

Reply

lorannah April 4 2008, 23:27:21 UTC
Thank you. :D

Reply


ivy_b April 4 2008, 20:49:25 UTC
Awww what a great ending. Still feel bad for John though and I know Jack's lying- they had something, even if it wasn't love- but obviously he wouldn't tell John that. Adam got what was coming to him (even if he might not be dead) everyone's broken, it's not a happy ending, but there is hope and a chance to rebuild. Loved it.

Reply

lorannah April 4 2008, 23:29:27 UTC
Thank you.

Don't worry, Jack was completely (well mostly) lying. I really, sort of, wish John could have stayed around.

And I'm glad the not-quite-happy ending worked.

:D

Reply


Leave a comment

Up