watch thou for the mutant

Nov 05, 2012 10:43

I have a confession to make: I am possibly the entire person in the world who doesn't like Quakers. Seriously. I googled "criticism of Quakers" and the only thing I go was this, which at least didn't make me feel totally insane, since a lot of the criticisms he relates are ones I share ( Read more... )

deep fucking thoughts, gdi my pain is valid, social justice, i'm allowed to have feelings

Leave a comment

lions_wings November 6 2012, 04:10:30 UTC
It gets a little trickier when interdependence intersects with the Geek Social Fallacy, at the end of which people who should have been excluded from the group for creepy behavior are nonetheless held in the group because shunning is bad and wrong. And hell, I had a narrow escape a bit ago from a situation where a group had gotten the mindset that they should receive attention and friendship in exchange for geekly social interaction. They were putting the cart before the horse, but once I got far enough to look at it calmly, it reminded me not so much of a cult as a multi-level marketing scheme of friendship. Like, a very sophisticated social strategy to cater to a basically unhealthy and antisocial mindset.

It's a little like the "happy families are all alike; unhappy families are unhappy in their own way." Including everyone in a community can easily include people and groups that undermine the community, possibly intentionally. From your spoiled child who got others to remove people at her whim, to my crazy person who assured me that even though I was very sick, I still had something to give them. I am very bad at finding a solution because when I'm not comfortable and can't talk it out, I sever ties.

The Quakers were historically the most bro-ish of the American Christian groups, minding their own business while the other sects were ostracizing and witchhunting each other, and opposing the slave trade, and all that good stuff. So I am sorry they sucked so hard.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up