Weekly Limerick Contest

Dec 15, 2009 18:15

Poll Weekly Limerick Review

Leave a comment

Comments 9

foxfirefey December 17 2009, 09:46:55 UTC
So, I mean these suggestions very nicely:

1. I feel like I should note that when you post the limericks as images only, with no alt text, it means that people using screen readers can't vote on them. I know you don't mean to do that, and thought you might want to know.
2. I'm not sure if this is the way the poll is supposed to be, and I know the polls are really confusing to navigate, but this poll is a multiple choice question instead of a choose one question. You're describing it like you want people to select one but the poll doesn't enforce it. At this point, I don't know whether you want people to select only one, or if you want people to select the all ones they liked, so either double check the type of question next time or describe it more fully.

Reply

You are correct on both counts ... bluemeringue December 17 2009, 15:48:58 UTC
I hadn't realized the images wouldn't render. I couldn't use the poll tool to post the limericks (there is a draconian character limit), so I came up with this solution on the fly (I didn't want to link to full limericks, since I thought it was more equitable to have only one stanza per poet). Ah well. I will try linking to them next time.

As for the multiple choice thang. I chose radial buttons as usual. Seems to have cropped up all on its own. After I discovered it (i.e., after it was discovered via a kindly writer), I was going to pull and repost, but I thought it was unfair since votes had already been entered.

I sincerely appreciate your thoughtful/constructive suggestions. I love this community to sharp, pointy bits and pieces. I will work toward improving it.

Reply

Re: You are correct on both counts ... the_hatstand December 17 2009, 15:54:52 UTC
Alternatively you could quote all the limericks first, then run the poll beneath them using a radio button to choose between 1,2,3,4 or 5.

Reply

Re: You are correct on both counts ... bluemeringue December 17 2009, 17:34:18 UTC
Thank you ... Evidently, my luddite roots are showing. I will follow your advice!

Reply


bookishfellow December 17 2009, 14:31:03 UTC
@my_stitching: Yours would have gotten my vote, but the scansion doesn't work in the last line. Strict adherence to meter is essential to a good limerick, unless you're messing with it deliberately as part of the joke. Suggestion: replace "he is" with "the man is" or "the fella's."

Reply


limericks vote mrs_ptarmigan December 23 2009, 03:04:54 UTC
I vote for the Hatstand!

Reply


mymymiaow December 28 2009, 10:23:52 UTC
I have one too on the subject of insomnia:

Once a man who liked Earl Grey
Drank the tea and cried 'hooray'.
Then he stayed up all the night
And his maid said he's a knight
And had more tea brought on tray.

Once a man who was all grey
Drank the tea that was Earl Grey.
Then he rode but couldn't move
And his horse broke up a hoof
But his keenness wouldn't fray.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up