disk vs disc?

Sep 29, 2010 13:19

Hello all ( Read more... )

english, computer technology, computers

Leave a comment

nofaves September 29 2010, 17:48:52 UTC
CD is officially short for compact disc, spelled with a c.

But let's add to your confusion! Before audio CDs, we had records, which were also called 'discs' with a c. But before computer CDs, we had floppy disks and hard disk drives, both spelled with a k.

Reply

thaichicken September 29 2010, 17:52:27 UTC
So what I gather from that is that "disc" means something round, and "disk" means "computer equipment on which you can save data"? Is that the nuance I was missing?

Reply

nofaves September 29 2010, 18:10:10 UTC
Actually, "disk" means something round. That spelling is older than "disc."

Something interesting I found out in my own Googling, though: when I was a kid, back pain sufferers often had "slipped disks" and sometimes drove cars with "disk brakes." Both of those terms have begun to switch to the "disc" spelling.

Reply

ubykhlives September 30 2010, 00:06:14 UTC
Actually, "disk" means something round. That spelling is older than "disc."

In fairness, there's variation even in OED's very earliest citations. Even though OED does say that the earlier spelling is disk, I don't think it's fair to argue that one is significantly older than the other. Ephraim Chambers' Cyclopædia is OED's second-earliest citation, dating 1727-1751, and even as early as that it gives both disc and disk as variants. (Obviously disc would have been influenced by Latin discus, even if its proximate origin were from French disque, and disk would have been directly from Greek δίσκος. OED's earliest citation is from Pope's translation of the Iliad, which naturally would have gone with the Hellenicising form.)

I'm actually quite surprised at OED here - they've taken an unusual prescriptive stance, or at least they have in the online article: "The earlier and better spelling is disk" (my bold, their italics).

Reply

conuly October 3 2010, 19:34:41 UTC
Floppy disks have round somethings as well. The square outside of it isn't the disk part.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up