R8CH7 - voting

Dec 05, 2014 23:47


Voting
Challenge 7

The following failed to submit an icon or chose to use a skip:
fassy (0)
novindalf (0)

Vote here )

-voting, round 8

Leave a comment

Comments 8

delacours December 6 2014, 04:20:48 UTC
r08ch07 Voting
One Lesser Quality
#2 - I love the coloring and the idea, though the background doesn't really blend well (I think a lighter shade of color would have looked better) and you can see the original background that wasn't completely erased on the edges.

One Better Quality
#1 - Gorgeous coloring, texture and text use.

Reply


naive_astronaut December 6 2014, 13:30:21 UTC
r08ch07 Voting
One Lesser Quality
#3 - doctor's face looks a bit washed out

One Better Quality
#2

Reply


novindalf December 6 2014, 14:29:49 UTC
r08ch07 Voting
One Lesser Quality
#3 - The icon is a bit too sharp, and also it looks like you've erased a bit too much of his hair/head and it looks a bit weird. I love the texture use and colours though.

One Better Quality
#2

Reply


setentpet December 6 2014, 19:40:28 UTC
r08ch07 Voting
One Lesser Quality
#3 - The use of negative space is nice but the icon is a little over sharpened and the Doctor's muted coloring doesn't really match well with the bright blue of the background.

One Better Quality
#1 - The text is a little hard to read but the coloring and composition are great.

Reply


julie_izumi December 7 2014, 11:40:47 UTC
r08ch07 Voting
One Lesser Quality
3 - The negative space is nice but the coloring lacks of unity, Ten is looking too yellow and lacks of contrast.

One Better Quality
1 - Really pretty composition, text placement and coloring!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up