Voting

Jan 21, 2017 18:11

VOTING | CHALLENGE #1

The following chose to use a skip or didn't enter an icon so a skip has been used for them:
wickedvengeance (0)
dine7184 (0)
hermionesparkle (0)
adriftingsea (1)

May the Force be with you )

!voting

Leave a comment

Comments 10

hermionesparkle January 22 2017, 06:04:21 UTC
Ch. #1 Voting

One Lesser Quality
#3 - the muted coloring of the subject makes it blend into the background. it could have done better with the subject a touch lighter or sharper to add some contrast.

One Favorite
#1 - nice coloring and use of the background.

Reply


violateraindrop January 22 2017, 10:07:47 UTC
Ch. #1 Voting

One Lesser Quality
3 - The whole icon looks very dark and lacks contrast. It has a rather muddy look and it does not seem as if a lot has happened with the cap apart from cropping it. There is nothing that makes it stand out or that you focus on while looking at the icon. Adding some light, contrast and color would be nice.

One Favorite
5 - I really like the added color!

Reply


novindalf January 22 2017, 11:00:18 UTC
Ch. #1 Voting

One Lesser Quality
#3 - The crop is nice but the colouring is a bit dull and flat - adding some gradients or more lighting might help!

One Favorite
#1 - Love the stars in her goggles/glasses! Also great crop and lighting!

Reply


sietepecados January 22 2017, 17:42:59 UTC
Ch. #1 Voting

One Lesser Quality
#3 - This is really hard! This one looks a bit too dark and blurry on my screen and it makes it looks flat.

One Favorite
#1 - I love the space texture in place of her visor.

Reply


naginis January 22 2017, 18:22:41 UTC
Ch. #1 Voting

One Lesser Quality
#2 - The crop is nice, but the subject blends too much into the background as they are both gray. Adding some shading or contrast could help.

One Favorite
#5

Reply


Leave a comment

Up