Comments | lims_btvs: Round #1 - Challenge #2

hermionesparkle in lims_btvs

Round #1 - Challenge #2 - Results

Aug 31, 2009 21:40

Thanks to everyone who voted! Unfortunately we had a tie so 2 people are being eliminated this challenge. Surprising turnout in my opinion. New challenge will be up soon.

Eliminated:

( Read more... )

challenge2, results, round1

Comments 11

setentpet September 1 2009, 01:50:42 UTC

thanks for MC and the banner!!

congrats to darlingbones

americangrl69 September 1 2009, 02:31:20 UTC

4 please!

hermionesparkle September 2 2009, 00:05:23 UTC

#4 - Overuse of textures and the icon was not cut out well.
#4 - bad use of cropping , textures do not appeal to the icon.

note_sarcasm September 1 2009, 06:40:53 UTC

can i please get the comments for mine?
whats the point of voting for a + one when it doesnt go into the tally?

sianna_sm September 1 2009, 11:07:45 UTC

Well yeah I don't get it either! There is no point in voting for favourite this way. That's not even math it's like 2+2 everybody can count it.
Anyway, congrats darlingbones ! Lovely icon <3 Good luck with the next rounds =)

note_sarcasm September 1 2009, 12:02:49 UTC

yeah with all my lims comms i have added the + points.
i thought your icons was fantastic!

hermionesparkle September 2 2009, 00:03:52 UTC

Last time I checked adding 2+2 is math. :P I don't count well so that's why I don't do it the way other communities do. I may change it next round.

Thread 6

purely_distel September 1 2009, 09:58:05 UTC

hey there :) Just a short question - wouldn't it be more practical for you to unscreen all the votes after voting is over? That way we can see what people had to say about our icons and you won't have to copy them back and forth :) It's just what I've seen happening in other LIMS and it seemed rather practical.

Oh and it kinda is true what a person further down said. If only the negative votes are counted without taking the positive ones into account ... it's a bit unpractical. If you want to, I can help you with that. You know, do the math so to speak ^^

But, I don't want to step on your toes or anything, just suggesting :)

hermionesparkle September 2 2009, 00:14:36 UTC

I have done that before at my other lims community but since the identity behind the votes were revealed when unscreened them, it shows who is voting for what & believe it or not, it caused problems. I have thought about trying it again. I really appreciate the feedback & the offer of help. I'm going to make a post addressing this issue soon & try to come up with a solution to be fair to everybody.