round five; challenge seven; results
Thanks to everyone who participated!!! :D Great icons!! Just remember, if you have time to make an icon, you have time to vote you don't have to give reasons if you can't think of any! Thank you to all of you that gave crit!
So sorry for the delay on this! I had a busy busy week. Challene 8 is temporarily extended, so coffee_scented , octagonal , loversopolite you have 24 hours (until tomorrow Jan 17th, at 1PM EST to enter) :) Challenge 9 will be posted later today!
First (tie)
(5 pts) Second
(4 pts) Third
(3 pts)
absolutelybatty shamethebells
w/ 12 votes sallyna_smile
w/ 10 votes _puchula_
w/ 9 votes
Best Crop
(2 pt) Mod's Choice
(2 pt)
shamethebells
w/ 8 votesalorarose
TALLIES:
votes / special category
♥ = # of special category votes
~ = concrit
+ Great crop, lovely simple icon.
+ no reasons given loversopolite
02/00
+++ no reasons given
++ great texture use
++ Love the texture use.
++ no reasons given
+ Could have used a bit more light on Jennsen's face, but otherwise a wonderful choice of cap/crop and pretty texture use.
sallyna_smile
10/00
+++ Love the coloring and glowing quality.
+ lovely coloring and I like the softness of the overall image
+ no reasons given sourpony
05/00
+++ no reasons given
+++ Brilliant concept and well executed.
++ great blending of thw bw part and the colored one, and the cropping is quite catching
++ I love the play on light and dark, color and black and white, side by side on this icon. The close crop of Nicci on the right as it plays against the negative space created on the left, it's just wonderfully constructed.
++ I like the use of both Niccis for this icon
absolutelybatty
12/00
+ no reasons given
♥♥
xbellaxdivax
01/02
++ no reasons given
+ nice crop and color bella_farfalla
03/00
+++ love everything about this icon. texture, coloring, composition are all lovely.
+++ Love the composition.
+++ it looks like Zedd is crawling out of a window, which is pretty interesting
♥
_puchula_
09/01
++ clean and crisp quality. excellent crop
++ Pretty, soft coloring and a great crop.
♥♥♥alorarose
04/03
+ Denna looks so soft and pretty, I really like the coloring octagonal
01/00
+++ I love the composition and the combination of texture/color is greatle done!
+++ The purple is so unusual and striking that it just stands out from the rest. It's beautiful.
+++ Great cropping and stunning colouring
++ no reasons given
+ great coloring and crop
♥♥♥♥
shamethebells
12/04
+ The crop is just close enough that it doesn't swallow the icon with the little bit of room to the side of her face. The reddish tones on her face are beautiful, giving her just enough to highlight the eyes and lips without overpowering the icon.
♥ wildalyss
01/00
Congratulations!
You can view the tally board here. Feel free to check it whenever you see fit.
So sorry for the delay on this! I had a busy busy week. Challene 8 is temporarily extended, so coffee_scented , octagonal , loversopolite you have 24 hours (until tomorrow Jan 17th, at 1PM EST to enter) :) Challenge 9 will be posted later today!
First (tie)
(5 pts) Second
(4 pts) Third
(3 pts)
absolutelybatty shamethebells
w/ 12 votes sallyna_smile
w/ 10 votes _puchula_
w/ 9 votes
Best Crop
(2 pt) Mod's Choice
(2 pt)
shamethebells
w/ 8 votesalorarose
TALLIES:
votes / special category
♥ = # of special category votes
~ = concrit
+ Great crop, lovely simple icon.
+ no reasons given loversopolite
02/00
+++ no reasons given
++ great texture use
++ Love the texture use.
++ no reasons given
+ Could have used a bit more light on Jennsen's face, but otherwise a wonderful choice of cap/crop and pretty texture use.
sallyna_smile
10/00
+++ Love the coloring and glowing quality.
+ lovely coloring and I like the softness of the overall image
+ no reasons given sourpony
05/00
+++ no reasons given
+++ Brilliant concept and well executed.
++ great blending of thw bw part and the colored one, and the cropping is quite catching
++ I love the play on light and dark, color and black and white, side by side on this icon. The close crop of Nicci on the right as it plays against the negative space created on the left, it's just wonderfully constructed.
++ I like the use of both Niccis for this icon
absolutelybatty
12/00
+ no reasons given
♥♥
xbellaxdivax
01/02
++ no reasons given
+ nice crop and color bella_farfalla
03/00
+++ love everything about this icon. texture, coloring, composition are all lovely.
+++ Love the composition.
+++ it looks like Zedd is crawling out of a window, which is pretty interesting
♥
_puchula_
09/01
++ clean and crisp quality. excellent crop
++ Pretty, soft coloring and a great crop.
♥♥♥alorarose
04/03
+ Denna looks so soft and pretty, I really like the coloring octagonal
01/00
+++ I love the composition and the combination of texture/color is greatle done!
+++ The purple is so unusual and striking that it just stands out from the rest. It's beautiful.
+++ Great cropping and stunning colouring
++ no reasons given
+ great coloring and crop
♥♥♥♥
shamethebells
12/04
+ The crop is just close enough that it doesn't swallow the icon with the little bit of room to the side of her face. The reddish tones on her face are beautiful, giving her just enough to highlight the eyes and lips without overpowering the icon.
♥ wildalyss
01/00
Congratulations!
You can view the tally board here. Feel free to check it whenever you see fit.