Section One Negative Votes (-1 points): #01 - the spot of colour on the b/w image and background texture don't compliment the image.
Positive Votes (+2 points): #05 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Section Two Negative Votes (-1 points): #03 - While I like the idea of the double image, this isn't executed well. the top half just shows part of Richard's chin and his (not naked!) shoulders and this isn't a very striking image, especially since so much of it is black. Positive Votes (+2 points): #04 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Section One Negative Votes (-1 points): #02 - The one side of his face is too dark and the other is too blurred. The icon needs to be sharpened.
Positive Votes (+2 points): #01 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Section Two Negative Votes (-1 points): #04 - The smudging of the background is awkward and indecisive; either smudge everything or more defined and I think it would have worked better.
Positive Votes (+2 points): #01 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Comments 6
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #01 - the spot of colour on the b/w image and background texture don't compliment the image.
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #05 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Section Two
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #03 - While I like the idea of the double image, this isn't executed well. the top half just shows part of Richard's chin and his (not naked!) shoulders and this isn't a very striking image, especially since so much of it is black.
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #04 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Reply
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #02 - The one side of his face is too dark and the other is too blurred. The icon needs to be sharpened.
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #01 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Section Two
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #04 - The smudging of the background is awkward and indecisive; either smudge everything or more defined and I think it would have worked better.
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #01 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Reply
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #03 - The image is too blurry and the crop could have been more specific
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #04
Section Two
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #02 - too much use of white spot lights
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #01
Reply
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #03 - This icon is a bit on the blurry side and just doesn't show the level of skill that the others do..
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #05 - This icon is sharpened and colored beautifully.
Section Two
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #01 - Its a beautiful icon but its too dark on his face and body, and you can't see him clearly.
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #02 - The black and white it done beautifully and the icon is very dramatic.
Reply
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #03 - The icon is a bit blurry and pixely.
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #02 - Great use of b/w
Section Two
Negative Votes
(-1 points): #04 - Too much contrast. The icon comes out 'flat'
Positive Votes
(+2 points): #05 - Reasons optional but encouraged.
Reply
Leave a comment