(Untitled)

May 16, 2006 11:02

I should have known better than to post something of significance on a Friday.

So I'll ask again.  :)

As you may have deduced (the sharp cognitive skills of
Read more... )

Leave a comment

moonlitwoods May 27 2006, 20:18:29 UTC
...
I haven't forgotten about this. I'm still mulling. The problem is, most of the questions I'd like to have answered either will be in the final book -- and therefore are questions JKR is unlikely to answer -- or they are unlikely to be resolved at all because they are too specific.

I really like May's question about whether or not Dumbledore's death had been foretold to him.

A few of the questions I could offer now are:

(1) After the series is finished, would/will JKR consider publishing a set of Potter encyclopedias of sorts, one that would contain the full background and details she's created for all the characters, including her maps and sketches?

(2) If the effects had the potential to be so far-reaching and catastrophic, why did McGonagall (or Dumbledore for that matter) trust the then 13-year-old Hermione with a Timeturner just to complete additional classwork? Was the Timeturner a contrivance for Prisoner only, or will the device figure in the final book?

(3) Did Snape leave his supposed "worst memory" unattended purposely, knowing that nosey young Potter would look and be disillusioned by the behavior of his father and beloved godfather?

(4) Was Remus Lupin estranged from James, Lily, and Sirius at the time of the Potters' death, and/or had he done something specific to make Sirius mistrust him, causing Sirius to withhold the Secret-Keeper switch from him?

That's enough for now. If I think of any more that are even remotely suitable I'll let you know. :)
...

Reply


Leave a comment

Up