Round 5 // Challenge 7 Results

[shadowserenity]

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is kereia.

Comments

[quiddity_]

I survived vacation \o/
Thanks for mod's choice. :)

[shadowserenity]

Yay for survival! :) I liked your icon from the beginning :).

- Great coloring and crop
- goooorgeous! i love that it looks like she's on a bed--a bed underwater. very unique icon!

[linesfade]

Comments for #6, please? Thank you!

[shadowserenity]

- nice cropping and lighting.
- she looks a little too flatly orange - her skin is the same color as her hair, and there's an odd faded spot which kind of brings attention to her chest and away from her face.
- why is teyla so orange? the icon looks nice, but her body being orange seems a bit unnatural.

[shadowserenity]

- fantastic contrast and coloring
- [the coloring on teyla is a little too dark creating this awkward dark spot in the icon]
- [lovely coloring and lighting]
- I really like the colours in this icon. The compositon works very well with this background.

[meganlynn09]

I'm sorry I wasn't around to vote, was away! But there were some amazing icons this round :D

Would love comments for #15, unscreened fine. Thank you.

[shadowserenity]

- good color and interesting crop.
- The coloring and clarity is really nice, but the crop seems very awkward to me. Her eye is caught right in the corner, and it gives it an odd look. My own eye keeps getting drawn to that scary eyeball.
- [Interesting angle/crop and nice, clean coloring.]
- poor image quality; I think the colouring just highlights some of the image issues I also had when I tried to work with the cap; the pixellation is especially apparent around Keller's jawline.

[beeej]

Still here! \o/ Comments for #4, please! Unscreened is fine, thanks!

[shadowserenity]

- the lighting, the softness, the crop, everything is done wonderfully
- [good blend with background, good lighting, good color mix]