Round 5 // Challenge 3 Alternates

[shadowserenity]

Did you create a few icons for the challenge and then choose the best one to submit? If so, this is where you can post those "rejected" icons (along with your submitted entry) and make them sharable to others :).

Comments

[jenniferjensen]

okay, that didn't last long :( should have picked a different one for submitting I think.

Entered:

[jehnt]

pffft I still like your submitted one best. The other two are just plain icons. There's nothing wrong with them, but they don't make me think, "hey, that looks awesome, wish I'd thought of it!" either.

[jenniferjensen]

Thanks! I still like my entered icon too! i though it was a cool idea and I've never seen it done before.

[casett]

:(

I really like the idea of your entered icon but it needs something more to make it pop and understandable. But, good for you as it wasn't the safe choice! Your first alternate has interesting unfilled space and nice clarity.

[jenniferjensen]

thanks, it was a huge decision on which one to enter the first or second icon. In a bold move I didn't go with the safe choice and sometimes it gets you unlimited, oh well.

[casett]

But you can feel good that you took a chance. Sometimes playing in traffic is more fun ;-)

[jenniferjensen]

Thanks!