Comments | keyboardninja: One more round on Council, this time with SMD

keyboardninja

One more round on Council, this time with SMD

Dec 03, 2008 23:33

Bold = Eddie, the CM for SMD
Not bold = My responses

( This one is kind of long )

Back to all threads

Conclave perpetuallysad December 4 2008, 05:58:46 UTC

Nearly everybody managed to show up at this Conclave and make some sort of awesome happen and we're ass-raping the guy that didn't do it that way? How would this look on the other end, "Dale brought the sixth Justicar to this event and didn't even *prop*!!! How ridiculous is it that one game gets so many Justicars?" You old council hats may recognize that one.

The simple truth here is that the decision was calculated. Rather than calling Dale defensive [ despite the truth of it :-P ], there should be an attack on the logic of that decision and how Other Guy would do better [don't know who other guy is]. Until I see that, well who gives a shit? Drama Assaults just aren't valuable. Don't spend so much time destroying our confidence in one person rather than raising our confidence in somebody else.

Re: Conclave retailgod December 4 2008, 07:50:45 UTC

That's the thing. The other guy isn't on council, has almost no org experience, and absolutely no Brujah experience. Kind of ridiculous.

Re: Conclave keyboardninja December 4 2008, 10:24:28 UTC

It's okay, though, because I'm the debil for not a) killing Pompeii already, b) forcing the Brujah to be utter screw-ups so they have no perceived power, and c) not bringing my Justicar to an already full house, when it wasn't really necessary.

Really, who can argue with that logic? It's obvious that I'm a horrible, horrible person because I did what my application last year actually said I would do.

Re: Conclave internofdoom December 4 2008, 11:11:58 UTC

You hit the nail on the head, Dael. All the arguments against you lack cohesion. It is all about a personal grudge and everyone knows it.

Re: Conclave capnstinkypants December 4 2008, 16:47:11 UTC

Ding Ding Ding Truth!

Re: Conclave internofdoom December 4 2008, 16:59:12 UTC

It's not some massive revalation, either. I think Nick put it best with the 'everyone who is not dead knows what is going on'.

The only thing that makes it even notable at all is the massive self-delusion attempt being made by some on the other side.

Re: Conclave keyboardninja December 4 2008, 17:25:50 UTC

There are personal grudges on both sides of the fence. I'm just trying to clear up what I believe to be misconceptions and false assumptions as best I can.

Re: Conclave internofdoom December 4 2008, 17:31:33 UTC

>There are personal grudges on both sides of the fence.

No kidding. The difference is that none of us have a beef with Vinny.

Re: Conclave keyboardninja December 4 2008, 17:49:34 UTC

No. My only problem with Vinny is his lack of any experience whatsoever with OWbN Brujah genre.

Back to all threads