Short Negative HPV Post

Jul 15, 2010 20:33

 This shouldn't take too long.  Someone I know who is way into the woo contracted HPV-caused genital warts a few years ago.  I haven't asked about the details of his infection, such as frequency or duration.  I just know he actually got the warts, most presumably from a partner who also had warts about a year before his first wart showed up.

Anyway, because he's way into the woo, he didn't get them frozen off or burned off, which is the typical method of treatment (which, btw, only removes the wart, not the virus - this can cause relief from the itchy/burning symptoms, and it is currently believed that the virus is less-transmissible when there are no physical symptoms - but it can still be transmitted).  No, he sought out a "natural remedy".  It's called D-lenolate, which sounds all medicine-like, but don't let the name fool you.

As Dara O'Brian says, "Herbal medicine has been around for thousands of years!  Indeed it has, and then we tested it all, and the stuff that worked became 'medicine'!  And the rest of it is just a nice bowl of soup and some potpourri."

So anyway, he took this stuff and his warts went away.  Therefore, this extract of olive leaf must have cured his HPV.  It couldn't be because warts come and go on their own whims or anything.  Nothing like some confirmation bias, eh?

I found it hard to believe that I wouldn't have heard of this particular remedy if it had been real, so I looked it up.  Turns out, I was right.

Every link that shows up in Google goes to a "natural wellness" store selling this crap, and one link goes to a 2006 cease and desist letter from the FDA saying this one company can't claim this shit cures anything or else it has to be classified as a drug.  And if it's a drug, then it needs to go through proper channels of FDA approval before it makes its claims.  Since it didn't go through proper channels, it can't make the claims.  Basically, it claims to be a "natural antibiotic" (psst! antibiotics kill bacteria, not viruses, and antibiotics are not recommended for treatment of viruses except in very specific cases where opportunistic bacterial colonization is a threat) that "boosts the immune system".

Just as an easy-to-remember rule of thumb, if something claims to 'boost the immune system", that's usually a good sign that these people have no idea how the immune system works and are cashing in on our ignorance with fancy, sciencey-sounding words.  You should automatically be suspicious when you see that red flag.  Legitimate, tested medicine does not claim to 'boost the immune system" because that's not how the immune system works (from the ever-snarky Mark Crislip, infectious disease specialist).

So then I looked it up on PubMed, which is the number one resource to see what tests have been done and filed with legitimate science-based organizations and are up for (or have been) peer reviewed.  Guess what?  Not a single mention of this stuff anywhere.  Not even a failed study.

In other words, IT HASN'T BEEN TESTED TO SHOW THAT IT DOES WHAT IT CLAIMS TO DO, which is cure or treat ANYTHING.

This doesn't mean that it does NOT do anything helpful.  It means that there is no evidence to suggest that it DOES do something helpful, and also no tests to make sure it's safe for human consumption.

If you have, or have been exposed to, HPV-Genital Warts, do yourself a favor and don't take the advice of "some guy".  Even if that "guy" is wearing a white lab coat.  Ask your doctor about the 3 or 4 freezing and burning methods.  They're uncomfortable, but warts are warts, and those are the only way to get rid of them.

Also, they might come back - it's a virus after all.  But don't take untested, unproven "remedies" - you don't know what that shit'll do.  If you're lucky, it won't do anything at all.

sti, warnings, science

Previous post Next post
Up