The Suicidalist Legacy

Sep 22, 2010 12:23

Continuing the analysis of Suicidalism and its effects on the West, begun in "Suicidalism" (earlier today, http://jordan179.livejournal.com/184945.html#cutid1Read more... )

suicidalism, politics, islamism, europe, philosophy, america, strategy, russia

Leave a comment

shockwave77598 September 22 2010, 21:25:00 UTC
Sure, what you say is true - nobody has a right to any sort of employment whatsoever. Hey, we can take this a step further too and tell every company that does business with the govt that if they wish to keep doing govt business, they'll fire everyone of their employees who are in the Republican party. Ooops, I meant fire everyone whose in the Democratic party. Actually, both will be right depending on who is in charge that particular date I suppose. But hey, if it's okay for you to do it to X then it's okay when X does it to you. Fair is fair is fair.

Telling people that they have to say only what the Govt says they can say or else, violates the very principles on which we established this nation. Not even King George went so far. And again, when the ideals of individual liberty are sacrificed for your illusion of safety, then we deserve neither liberty nor safety. Franklin said it best imho.

And I am not so sure about this liberal commie-bastion you seem to think exists in schools around the country. I attended UT Austin, which is supposed to be pretty liberal, and not once did I encounter any communists or socialist people, student or faculty. And if my kid's schools are any gauge, with their anal concern over even the tiniest rules, the public schools are more draconian than when I was a teen. You of course may feel free to see commie sympathizers behind every bush if you so choose. But my own experiences make me think they can be found as frequently as the North American Verigated Snipe.

Reply

irked_indeed September 22 2010, 21:33:20 UTC
Sure, what you say is true - nobody has a right to any sort of employment whatsoever. Hey, we can take this a step further too and tell every company that does business with the govt that if they wish to keep doing govt business, they'll fire everyone of their employees who are in the Republican party. Ooops, I meant fire everyone whose in the Democratic party. Actually, both will be right depending on who is in charge that particular date I suppose. But hey, if it's okay for you to do it to X then it's okay when X does it to you. Fair is fair is fair.

Yes, we can do these things- we, that is, you and I as individuals. We can tell these companies whatever we want, and spend our money in ways to incentivize them to listen.

It looks like you're reading Jordan as encouraging the government to do these things via force of law, which is not at all what I understand him to be saying. Is that true, or am I misreading you?

Reply

shockwave77598 September 22 2010, 21:47:14 UTC
that is how I'm reading his treatise, yes.

Reply

irked_indeed September 22 2010, 21:56:03 UTC
Okay. That's why you aren't understanding him: he's advocating that we, as private citizens, take the actions legally permitted us to discourage behaviors we don't like. He's advocating this, among other things, as a means of avoiding a government that would pass these kinds of laws.

Reply

irked_indeed September 22 2010, 21:59:29 UTC
Which is to say, you two actually agree with each other that the government telling people what to think or say would be a terrible idea and blatantly unconstitutional. Yes. Clearly it would.

Reply

shockwave77598 September 23 2010, 13:22:18 UTC
ah, I see where the miscommunication is. Thanks!

Reply

irked_indeed September 23 2010, 16:19:28 UTC
Sure.

As a general rule, if it isn't foreign policy, it's safe to assume Jordan is not urging the government to take action.

Reply

stryck September 22 2010, 21:48:36 UTC
Why do folks like you always seem to assume that the government must do everything? We have a civil society apart from the government.

Reply

mrbogey September 22 2010, 21:48:57 UTC
I don't think you're quite getting what he's saying.

Reply

typewriterking September 23 2010, 06:18:32 UTC
Again, you're babbling utter nonsense like a dementia-sufferer.

Reply

brezhnev September 24 2010, 06:11:37 UTC
When did you go to UT? I was there 1986-1991. The Young Communist League regularly had a table set up on the West Mall. So did the Trots, friends of the Maoist Shining Path guerillas, and several other hard-Left groups. I still have a collection of the posters they affixed to the trees. As for the Daily Texan, that was just legendary. The majority of the economics faculty and the English faculty were Marxists. I don't know about the rest of the departments, though.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up