First, I doubt Midamericon got any new money. All ~500 of VD's voters were eligible to nominate this year without paying money. (Sasquan voters carry over in the nominating phase.) To vote for a Hugo, they'll have to join Midamericon.
Second, I'm not clear how you think VD is going to use No Award. People are not automatons and are already referring to some of the Rabid Puppies' selections as human shields. (Reynolds, for one, asked explicitly to be removed from the list and was ignored.) Between that and the post-announcement withdrawals (Thomas May pulled out today) I expect it will be clear who's a hostage and who's a conspirator. In short, unless VD gets an actual majority, instead of his usual 10% to 20%, he can't force a No Award.
that changing the rules after you get your butt whipped sounds, well, weak-king-ish.) More like changing the rules when a small minority (~200 voters at last year's nominating round) hijack the process from ~800+ voters.
I've said this a number of times: Last year the Puppies got out the vote. Everybody else stayed in bed. I honestly don't see that any hijacking went on, unless your definition of "hijacking" is radically different from mine.
IIRC Bruce Schneier wrote that tinkering with the rules was a bad idea because of unintended consequences, and I agree with him. If EPH cuts down on the number of recs castable by one person, awards will be decided by fewer recs (it's decided by way too few to begin with) which makes all kinds of weirdness possible. If you really want to make logrolling a thing of the past, bring in another 25,000 people to the process. It's that simple.
Finally, don't underestimate Vox. I still find it hard to believe that he's done what he's already done. I'm unwilling to say what he can't do in the future.
Bruce Schneier was involved up to his eyebrows on the Making Light blog developing EPH.
People keep saying that the Puppies brought out the numbers. No they didn't. I did the math. The Puppies locked up last year's ballot with ~250 votes out of ~2100. Using my math or Chaos Horizon's math, they had at most ~1,000 people in the final stage out of ~5900.
Just eyeballing it, VD had ~400 votes out of 4015 this year. That's around 10% of the electorate - in line with prior performance. The only way it can be said that Puppies brought the numbers is in bringing out numbers of people to vote against them.
Which is not a bad thing. The argument of the assorted Puppies seems to be that a minority of feminist/literate/leftie/SJW types have hijacked science fiction through... some method... and the plan is to hijack it back. As in "Take this plane to Cuba!" "No, take it to Texas!" -- and somehow everything is all right. So by demonstrating that, in fact, it's not a minority of SF fans who have changed the flavour of the genre from the sausagefest of Asimov/Heinlein/Niven/Pournelle, they now fall back on the backup argument that they're a minority being oppressed by a cruel, heartless mob.
The truth is that conservatives should stick to reading contemporary fiction, and leave SF to those of us who thing the golden age is yet to come.
Second, I'm not clear how you think VD is going to use No Award. People are not automatons and are already referring to some of the Rabid Puppies' selections as human shields. (Reynolds, for one, asked explicitly to be removed from the list and was ignored.) Between that and the post-announcement withdrawals (Thomas May pulled out today) I expect it will be clear who's a hostage and who's a conspirator. In short, unless VD gets an actual majority, instead of his usual 10% to 20%, he can't force a No Award.
that changing the rules after you get your butt whipped sounds, well, weak-king-ish.) More like changing the rules when a small minority (~200 voters at last year's nominating round) hijack the process from ~800+ voters.
Reply
IIRC Bruce Schneier wrote that tinkering with the rules was a bad idea because of unintended consequences, and I agree with him. If EPH cuts down on the number of recs castable by one person, awards will be decided by fewer recs (it's decided by way too few to begin with) which makes all kinds of weirdness possible. If you really want to make logrolling a thing of the past, bring in another 25,000 people to the process. It's that simple.
Finally, don't underestimate Vox. I still find it hard to believe that he's done what he's already done. I'm unwilling to say what he can't do in the future.
Reply
Reply
People keep saying that the Puppies brought out the numbers. No they didn't. I did the math. The Puppies locked up last year's ballot with ~250 votes out of ~2100. Using my math or Chaos Horizon's math, they had at most ~1,000 people in the final stage out of ~5900.
Just eyeballing it, VD had ~400 votes out of 4015 this year. That's around 10% of the electorate - in line with prior performance. The only way it can be said that Puppies brought the numbers is in bringing out numbers of people to vote against them.
Reply
The truth is that conservatives should stick to reading contemporary fiction, and leave SF to those of us who thing the golden age is yet to come.
Reply
Leave a comment