If you have a chance, watch "The Root Of All Evil" series on YouTube, which is Richard Dawkins argument that religion itself is bad, and useless. In particular, there's an interview with a gentleman that Dawkins himself describes as "actually quite nice", but this gentleman thinks that adulterers should be put to death because of his religious views.
Why people think that a behavior that's existed for millenia can be elimited by just upping the punishment a little more each year, is totally beyond me. It's the definition of insanity to keep doing the same thing and expect different results.
I just mean the general attitude of always being "tougher on crime" as a preventative measure. Minimum sentences, three-strikes laws, and so on.
Punishment isn't as effective in stopping undesired behavior as determining the root incentive for that behavior, and eliminating that. But, of course, that's a lot more difficult than punishment after the fact, and it doesn't jibe well with the whole Eternity of Suffering religious dealio.
Maintaining societal order has always required some kind of system of punishment for when people don't play by the rules. Eliminating the root causes is not only difficult, but impossible in many cases.
This isn't something that's unique to dealing with a particular religious dogma, either. The atheist Soviets tried to creatue a purely secular society based on equality and they failed in the worst way.
Comments 7
Why people think that a behavior that's existed for millenia can be elimited by just upping the punishment a little more each year, is totally beyond me. It's the definition of insanity to keep doing the same thing and expect different results.
Reply
The desire to kill people based on religious beliefs (or lack thereof) is hardly a recent development.
Reply
Punishment isn't as effective in stopping undesired behavior as determining the root incentive for that behavior, and eliminating that. But, of course, that's a lot more difficult than punishment after the fact, and it doesn't jibe well with the whole Eternity of Suffering religious dealio.
Reply
This isn't something that's unique to dealing with a particular religious dogma, either. The atheist Soviets tried to creatue a purely secular society based on equality and they failed in the worst way.
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment