Academic Glee!

[jalenstrix]

...for I have received a published paper that I know enough about to actually respond confidently with, "Your argument is very odd, given your data. You give (A), but imply (A1) and (A2), which aren't the only things which could be supported by (A). It could be (B) or (C)! Explain yourself! Especially since you're purporting to falsify (B)!"

I shall write to the author today, I think. Hee.