3. The first time…fantasy come true or big disappointment?
The first time? To be honest, it was kind of surprising.
Sylar was about the last person I ever imagined losing my virginity too. Yes, we had this weird game going on for years; it was a game of cat and mouse with some really weird rules and dangerous outcomes. The game with him didn't really leave time for dating other men because of the fact that I had to constantly move and change my name to try to keep out of Sylar's reach.
The last time he found me, I was in Vegas. I never told him but there was a guy I had gone out with a couple times before Sylar showed up in my apartment but I figure he doesn't need to know. It wasn't like I was close to having sex with the guy. I really didn't think I was close to having sex with anyone. Sylar decided to change the game though and so he decided to basically "kidnap" me to go on a road trip. Maybe he was just tired of chasing me around or whatever but that was how things changed.
The first time we were together? I'm not even sure what town we were in but we were in some seedy motel when he caught me watching porn. Not because I was interested or anything, it was the only thing on and yes, I admit that I had been staring when he walked in. He loves to bug me about that still and he certainly did when he caught me. It lead to an interesting discussion about sex and, well, his past experiences. He only had a couple and I had none but it came out I was a bit jealous. Not for the reasons you might think but I was.
Of course we fought, we always tend to fight but then it came down to a challenge. The challenge came to him showing me how he could use his telekinesis for something other than fighting or hurting someone. That was also the first time he told me I was beautiful and then he kissed me. Kissing lead to touching and then....well, we had sex.
It was a surprise but the bigger surprise was that it continued because now we're in some kind of weird relationship and the sex thing happens on a regular basis but that's not the biggest twist.
I'll leave you to guess what that is.