Title:
Burnt Ash and Golden EyesAuthor:
trolllogicficsFandom: Psych/Supernatural
Why it must be read: So, not only is it plausible in an SPN sort of way, but it's plausible in a Psych sort of way. Which is to say very funny even when it's all kind of horrifying. It is really, insanely excellent and has Shawn's voice down to a T.
Also by the same author:
The What Comes Around'verse. Supernatural/Dark Angel, with tasty Sam 'n Alec goodness.