arbuus
in
indie_lims
ROUND #3 CHALLENGE #7 RESULTS
ELIMINATED-
neuroticalx with -6 votes
sorry and i hope you'll join us in the next round!
PEOPLE'S CHOICE-
whitestroke with +3 votes
MOD'S CHOICE-
scraps
though it comes off as very bold and distracting, that's exactly what i like about it! it's a very daring use of text and it's not bad at all!
RESULTS-
1: -2 +1
2: -4 +1
3: +3
4: -3 +2
5: -5
6: -6
7: -1
ICONS-
#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
#7
VOTES-
#1-
- the text is too overpowering
- Text is too blatant, font is too bold, colours don't fit the rest of the icon
+ Very interesting and colorful. :D
#2-
- seems a bit oversharp
- The edges of the smaller frame are too harsh. It just doesn't blend too well
- it's original and new, but the style doesn't work with this particular picture
- the contrast is a little too high and the cropping on the larger image is a bit off - there's no arm and it looks a bit weird
+ Great style, it's nice and simple
#3-
+ no reason given
+ I love the colouring and line and text and basically everything :)
+ no reason given
#4-
- the samller image could have been a bit bigger, the ++ corners are distracting^^
- Original, but the solution looks pretty awkward
- The colouring is not very good, it makes the image of a lesser quality
+ Very original!
+ Original! Great colours
#5-
- The cropping is kinda bland and the tiny text looks out of place
- the colouring's a little pale
- Low contrast, text is unreadable
- the colouring is really nice but the cropping is a bit plain and the text just looks slapped on and illegible
- The text is a bit hard to read
#6-
- a bit too dark, the border around the tiny text box is too bold, and compared to the rest of the picture the box is too "clean", it takes away the focus from the actual object
- The texture is kinda muddy/dark and the white box seems kinda distracting
- Too dark
- Too dark, random application of teensy text brush seems thoughtless
- the cropping is nice but the text box is too stark and the texture use looks weird on his arms
- The texture overpowers the icon and makes it rather dark
#7-
- It looks too dark
(let me know if i made any mistakes!)
neuroticalx with -6 votes
sorry and i hope you'll join us in the next round!
PEOPLE'S CHOICE-
whitestroke with +3 votes
MOD'S CHOICE-
scraps
though it comes off as very bold and distracting, that's exactly what i like about it! it's a very daring use of text and it's not bad at all!
RESULTS-
1: -2 +1
2: -4 +1
3: +3
4: -3 +2
5: -5
6: -6
7: -1
ICONS-
#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
#7
VOTES-
#1-
- the text is too overpowering
- Text is too blatant, font is too bold, colours don't fit the rest of the icon
+ Very interesting and colorful. :D
#2-
- seems a bit oversharp
- The edges of the smaller frame are too harsh. It just doesn't blend too well
- it's original and new, but the style doesn't work with this particular picture
- the contrast is a little too high and the cropping on the larger image is a bit off - there's no arm and it looks a bit weird
+ Great style, it's nice and simple
#3-
+ no reason given
+ I love the colouring and line and text and basically everything :)
+ no reason given
#4-
- the samller image could have been a bit bigger, the ++ corners are distracting^^
- Original, but the solution looks pretty awkward
- The colouring is not very good, it makes the image of a lesser quality
+ Very original!
+ Original! Great colours
#5-
- The cropping is kinda bland and the tiny text looks out of place
- the colouring's a little pale
- Low contrast, text is unreadable
- the colouring is really nice but the cropping is a bit plain and the text just looks slapped on and illegible
- The text is a bit hard to read
#6-
- a bit too dark, the border around the tiny text box is too bold, and compared to the rest of the picture the box is too "clean", it takes away the focus from the actual object
- The texture is kinda muddy/dark and the white box seems kinda distracting
- Too dark
- Too dark, random application of teensy text brush seems thoughtless
- the cropping is nice but the text box is too stark and the texture use looks weird on his arms
- The texture overpowers the icon and makes it rather dark
#7-
- It looks too dark
(let me know if i made any mistakes!)