ROUND #3 CHALLENGE #6 RESULTS

[arbuus]

ELIMINATED-
two, because there was a tie


cookiegirl506 with -8 votes
and


whatifmaybe with -8 votes

sorry and i hope you'll join us in the next round!

PEOPLE'S CHOICE-


retreat_repeat with +3 votes

MOD'S CHOICE-


neuroticalx
LOVE the colouring it's so 'magical', lol.

RESULTS-
1: -1 +1
2: -8
3: -8
4: +1
5: -2 +2
6: -1 +2
7: -2
8: -4
9: -1 +3

ICONS-

#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6

#7

#8

#9

VOTES-
#1-
- the colouring is nice but the font used could have been better
+ creative crop, intriguing text, very original

#2-
- too dark
- overcontrasted
- contrast is too dark, making the coloring look heavy on Julian's face
- The contrast is to high
- It looks kinda blurry
- saturation is too high
- Too dark, simple and contrasted
- lovely coloring and good composition but it is a bit oversharpened

#3-
- the colouring is weird, too reddish
- whatever texture was used, it's a bit overpowering, and the image could use more contrast
- it's a little blurry and too simple
- Too simple, looks like just a crop + resize
- The crop could be better
- it doesn't look like much has been done to the original icon. Contrast could have been increased slightly
- A bit blurry and I don't notice anything special done to it
- the coloring is kind of flat, not much contrast in the image

#4-
+ no reason given

#5-
- The icon looks of poor quality and is to bright
- Both pictures in the frame make it look crowded
+ Interesting composition
+ Lovely blending, good colours

#6-
- The blueish hair looks weird and the light spots are distracting
+ lovely colouring, cropping and great use of light textures
+ lovely cropping and colouring

#7-
- Random white square ruins icon
- The box looks out of place

#8-
- the black border is distracting and a bit too bold
- Too small, feels crowded in such a small space
- the cropping seems a little odd and the texture is out of place
- could use more contrast, it is hard to tell who it is in the image because it is somewhat small and dark

#9-
- Text looks out of place. Also, the top looks too dark and it's distracting
+ no reason given
+ The colouring and cropping are awesome!
+ I love the choice of text placement

(let me know if i made any mistakes!)