arbuus
in
indie_lims
ROUND #2 CHALLENGE #3 RESULTS
voted off-
by graceandtaste with -9 votes
and
by choosetoignore with -8 votes
people's choice-
by arbuus with +6 votes
mod's choice-
by thatgirlsoph
though the text is a bit hard to read, i really like the composition.
TALLIES
1: -1
2: -1 +3
3: -2 +1
4: -4
5: -1 +1
6: -8
7: -3 +2
8: -4
9: +6
10: -6
11: -3 +1
12: -9
COMMENTS
icon #1
1 negative vote
- the colouring isn't flattering
no positive votes
icon #2
1 negative vote
- i don't like the texture and the estructure of the picture, lost of face
3 positive votes
- Love the little crop at the top of the icon. The whole icon is really different and new
- Just amazing. Very cool composition, executed well, and the coloring is nice, too
- i like the composition
icon #3
2 negative vote
- the texture used makes the icon look 'dirty' (which possibly was the intention), but I don't think it goes that well with this specific picture
- the icon is blurred
1 positive vote
- The colouring is gorgeous! And I love the use of textures!
icon #4
4 negative votes
- It's kinda plain compared to most of the other icons
- Too simple, rough edges
- I do not really have a reason, but one icon is missing
- The blue brush used distracts attention off the rest of the icon
no positive votes
icon #5
1 negative vote
- Again, too simple and rough. The style is to "square", too clean
1 positive vote
- i like the cropping and overall composition
icon #6
8 negative votes
- It's too blurry
- It's very simple. And the yellow text doesn't really work
- The "er" is a little hard to read
- Doesn't look like much work has been done to it. It's too dull and the font is plain
- Too blurry for my taste
- It's incredibly rough, the elements don't "blend" properly
- the border is too big and the picture is blurred
- there's too little contrast
no positive votes
icon #7
3 negative votes
- don't think the light texture goes with the picture
- Very simple icon, comparing to most of the other ones. It doesn't offer anything else but coloring
- the image seems overlighted and the lighteffects don't work here
2 positive votes
- the colouring is really good and the light texture works with the whole icon
- no reason given
icon #8
4 negative votes
- The estructure, I don't know, is like old west
- the texture contrasts with the text and the picture (which is very plain)
- The texture used looks too ovrsharpened. And the picture is very plain and doesn't look like a lot has been done to it
- I think there is too little colour on the icon and I don't like the bluish tinge on the black and white picture
no positive votes
icon #9
no negative votes
6 positive votes
- It was a tough call between this and #04, but the colouring on this icon is just to die for
- love the color and use of text
- I love the placing of the K and the T, and also the colouring is really pretty!
- I really like the font and the colouring
- no reason given
- no reason given
icon #10
6 negative vote
- the black&withe doesnt go well with the blue
- regina look's like a sick person i dont like it
- The text doesn't rally make sense to me. I like the txture but I never like it when people make eyes stand out. Especially when they're not the true colour, it makes them stand out too much and looks very unnatural.
- Bad placing of text. It makes the icon seem off-balance
- I think the cropping is a liitle off
- the texture looks weird next to the harshly contrasted image, and the font seems misplaced
no positive vote
icon #11
3 negative votes
- I like the repetead image but the colouring is too dark and dull
- The cropping isn't very good
- the colouring is way too brown/beige
1 positive vote
- love the color and the efect
icon #12
9 negative votes
- It's too bright, she looks deadly pale
- I don't like the way the picture is rotated around. And the blue brush isn't very nice either
- odd cropping and the coloring is too bright
- It looks too cluttered
- This is a very cool idea, but... I can't put my finger on it. Are the subjects a bit too big OR maybe they're just too close to one another. But it just doesn't work well on this icon. :/
- The duplicates and the brushes makes the icon somewhat messy
- the colouring is a little pale
- The picture has been rotated and it doesn't really work
- the blue scribble isn't that nice and the rotated image isn't that flattering either
no positive votes
BAD HABITS
I'm way too damn lazy and keep pushing everything to the last minute // Being bitchy - sometimes I just can't help it ... // fuck i have so many... well, i swear alot and im a bitch to people i dont know/like // Biting my nails! // I have a serious problem, I HAVE TO watch TV before I go to sleep and sometimes I have some REALLY bad nightmares // Biting my nails // Probably biting my nails. *does it as we speak* // Being a music nazi :P // Procrastinating // taking ages to think! // i'm lazy
by graceandtaste with -9 votes
and
by choosetoignore with -8 votes
people's choice-
by arbuus with +6 votes
mod's choice-
by thatgirlsoph
though the text is a bit hard to read, i really like the composition.
TALLIES
1: -1
2: -1 +3
3: -2 +1
4: -4
5: -1 +1
6: -8
7: -3 +2
8: -4
9: +6
10: -6
11: -3 +1
12: -9
COMMENTS
icon #1
1 negative vote
- the colouring isn't flattering
no positive votes
icon #2
1 negative vote
- i don't like the texture and the estructure of the picture, lost of face
3 positive votes
- Love the little crop at the top of the icon. The whole icon is really different and new
- Just amazing. Very cool composition, executed well, and the coloring is nice, too
- i like the composition
icon #3
2 negative vote
- the texture used makes the icon look 'dirty' (which possibly was the intention), but I don't think it goes that well with this specific picture
- the icon is blurred
1 positive vote
- The colouring is gorgeous! And I love the use of textures!
icon #4
4 negative votes
- It's kinda plain compared to most of the other icons
- Too simple, rough edges
- I do not really have a reason, but one icon is missing
- The blue brush used distracts attention off the rest of the icon
no positive votes
icon #5
1 negative vote
- Again, too simple and rough. The style is to "square", too clean
1 positive vote
- i like the cropping and overall composition
icon #6
8 negative votes
- It's too blurry
- It's very simple. And the yellow text doesn't really work
- The "er" is a little hard to read
- Doesn't look like much work has been done to it. It's too dull and the font is plain
- Too blurry for my taste
- It's incredibly rough, the elements don't "blend" properly
- the border is too big and the picture is blurred
- there's too little contrast
no positive votes
icon #7
3 negative votes
- don't think the light texture goes with the picture
- Very simple icon, comparing to most of the other ones. It doesn't offer anything else but coloring
- the image seems overlighted and the lighteffects don't work here
2 positive votes
- the colouring is really good and the light texture works with the whole icon
- no reason given
icon #8
4 negative votes
- The estructure, I don't know, is like old west
- the texture contrasts with the text and the picture (which is very plain)
- The texture used looks too ovrsharpened. And the picture is very plain and doesn't look like a lot has been done to it
- I think there is too little colour on the icon and I don't like the bluish tinge on the black and white picture
no positive votes
icon #9
no negative votes
6 positive votes
- It was a tough call between this and #04, but the colouring on this icon is just to die for
- love the color and use of text
- I love the placing of the K and the T, and also the colouring is really pretty!
- I really like the font and the colouring
- no reason given
- no reason given
icon #10
6 negative vote
- the black&withe doesnt go well with the blue
- regina look's like a sick person i dont like it
- The text doesn't rally make sense to me. I like the txture but I never like it when people make eyes stand out. Especially when they're not the true colour, it makes them stand out too much and looks very unnatural.
- Bad placing of text. It makes the icon seem off-balance
- I think the cropping is a liitle off
- the texture looks weird next to the harshly contrasted image, and the font seems misplaced
no positive vote
icon #11
3 negative votes
- I like the repetead image but the colouring is too dark and dull
- The cropping isn't very good
- the colouring is way too brown/beige
1 positive vote
- love the color and the efect
icon #12
9 negative votes
- It's too bright, she looks deadly pale
- I don't like the way the picture is rotated around. And the blue brush isn't very nice either
- odd cropping and the coloring is too bright
- It looks too cluttered
- This is a very cool idea, but... I can't put my finger on it. Are the subjects a bit too big OR maybe they're just too close to one another. But it just doesn't work well on this icon. :/
- The duplicates and the brushes makes the icon somewhat messy
- the colouring is a little pale
- The picture has been rotated and it doesn't really work
- the blue scribble isn't that nice and the rotated image isn't that flattering either
no positive votes
BAD HABITS
I'm way too damn lazy and keep pushing everything to the last minute // Being bitchy - sometimes I just can't help it ... // fuck i have so many... well, i swear alot and im a bitch to people i dont know/like // Biting my nails! // I have a serious problem, I HAVE TO watch TV before I go to sleep and sometimes I have some REALLY bad nightmares // Biting my nails // Probably biting my nails. *does it as we speak* // Being a music nazi :P // Procrastinating // taking ages to think! // i'm lazy