So I got the look I was sort of going for, but only with the HQ mod. Heh. It's a bit too blurry without the HQ mod. So I might try a less blurry version and see how it looks without the HQ mod. Or just go back to the normal no-blurred-edge version. Things are always a bit blurry without the HQ mod anyway. It's a shame, really, because I do really like the effect of the blurry border with the HQ mod. But since the mod isn't supposed to be used for constant gameplay, I doubt many people really use it a lot unless they're doing photo shoots or something. Maybe I could upload this version for people who use the HQ mod or something. Or maybe people don't even mind this without the HQ mod anyway and perhaps they'd still like this as is. I don't know.
I'll try to work on the eye whites more in any case, I think. I'll probably fail at making a decent looking eye white, but might as well try.
With HQ mod:
Without HQ mod: