Comments | idkreeg: meme!

aesthetically in idkreeg

meme!

Jul 10, 2010 17:10

+/- icon meme

01. Pick 5-10 of your icons & provide a link to your icon community/journal.
02. People will reply with one positive thing about your icons & one bit of constructive criticism.
03. Criticism has to be constructive. No rudeness, wank, etc. Be polite.
04. Participate & pimp!

pimp

Read more... )

!meme

Comments 395

goes first~ atleast July 10 2010, 22:24:23 UTC

( ... )

Re: goes first~ puncture July 10 2010, 22:34:27 UTC

+ Your icons are always so clean and colorful!
- I'm not really into kpop that much so I can't use most of your icons haha :(

Re: goes first~ aesthetically July 10 2010, 22:57:53 UTC

+ your anime coloring, back when you were into anime, was one of my biggest inspirations. such good, bright colors.
- like Corrina said, I cannot use most of your icons, but they're nice to look at :)

Re: goes first~ denisitap July 11 2010, 05:00:40 UTC

I don't even know who they are, but I already took one. Your icons are clean and pretty.

tehseto July 10 2010, 22:27:18 UTC

tehseto | scientificons

( ... )

puncture July 10 2010, 22:36:24 UTC

+ Colors are vibrant, nice cropping, ETERNAL SONATA!
I have no criticism, keep up the good work :)

tehseto July 11 2010, 01:59:46 UTC

;3; Thank you! Glad to see another ES fan too!

cool_spectrum July 11 2010, 01:49:17 UTC

+ I love the colors in your icons. They're vivid and pull your attention!

- Some of your cropping looks funny, like the 7th where the character's eye is cut off at the top.

Thread 5

atomais July 10 2010, 22:32:38 UTC

baltics @ aurisu

( ... )

aesthetically July 10 2010, 23:20:19 UTC

+ I love how clean your manga coloring is ... ♥ I tried your tutorial the other day for icon coloring & it was so good o///o
- you need to make me icons >:3

atomais July 10 2010, 23:21:51 UTC

jgdfkhj COMING FROM YOU THAT MEANS A LOT you beastly manga colourer you ♥

/// ask me nicely... C:

aesthetically July 10 2010, 23:24:45 UTC

FFFFFF O////O <3 <3 <3

dude, if you would, I'd be legit so happy?? it's like I love your icons, but you don't do most of my fandoms, so I'm in eternal woe

Thread 9

puncture July 10 2010, 22:33:26 UTC

puncture @ echodrop

( ... )

aesthetically July 10 2010, 22:56:49 UTC

+ your icons are so perfect. you inspire me so much.
- I cannot crit you, I swear. post more??

keepthelights July 28 2010, 23:43:08 UTC

+ sleek cropping, beautiful anime/manga coloring and i love the simplicity of them. it's my first time seeing your icons and they are gorgeous :)

- i really can't point anything.

whisper_lillies August 3 2010, 00:22:29 UTC

I cannot critique because I haven't seen enough, but I'm taking your Vanielle and watch your com now. :)

curiousity July 10 2010, 22:52:07 UTC

@ psychelocks

( ... )

cool_spectrum July 10 2010, 23:06:41 UTC

+ Your cropping is really good and I love your manga coloring!

- I think you should try playing with more textures. The coloring could have something in the background to make the icons pop even more!

ex_bel July 10 2010, 23:38:00 UTC

❤ you always pick really good images/styles of fanart or doujin to icon. like that's probably weird/oddly specific but I NOTICE THIS SHIT OKAY!!! your images always have this really sweet style/feel to them, idk if you look for that intentionally or if it's just how your aesthetic is but i like it, i need to...make you find pictures...for me...
✖ your coloring is kind of flat sometimes, like in #5 and 9; maybe play with saturation and selective coloring to get them to kind of pop out more?