0077: Eclipse Commentary Picspam

[make_me_irish]

Commentary picspam, because it's unreal how often Roberto and I were on the same page watching this.

Comments

[jewelsonthepage]

Rob: Again, Taylor did wanna be here but he has better stuff to do. He's working out right now. LMAO!

[Jacob: she's not sure what she wants] --worst line in all three flims for me. Rob: Yes she is! --Edward should have said this. Give the girl some brain credit.

Kristen: She doesn't know that they've leveled with each other.
Rob: They haven't leveled. Jacob hasn't learnt anything. --PERFECTION!

Rob: Him kissing her right now, God, it makes me...it proves how much of a....eurgh! He's like the worst guy in the world.
Kristen: She doesn't want to do it, she's just doing it to keep him there...
Rob: No, he's even worse than you in this scene. --He views Jacob, Bella, and Edward almost exactly as I did while reading. :)

Thanks for doing this, Steph! It's amazing, beautiful and soooo funny! I love it so much that I'm running over to tumblr right now to post it all via hotlink. ♥

[liliana_]

I actually agree with a lot of what Kristen said about the J/B kiss too. Just in that she totally got that it was about guilt, and I think that came across. Post-kiss, her world didn't look rocked, she looked sad and guilty.

[make_me_irish]

Yeah, I was so glad she added that. That she didn't want to do it, it was just a distraction thing. Because I think for anyone who hasn't read the book, that really doesn't come across.

[liliana_]

Yeah, I really didn't think they made it clear enough leading up to the kiss just how manipulative he was being, and they really should've left in the creepy "I know you can do better than that, Bella" line. But I did think as soon as the kiss was over, Kristen was all horror and guilt about it.

[make_me_irish]

With her internal thoughts, it kinda worked...until she went into all her other bullshit. But yeah, in the film that doesn't come across. But the fact that she was guilty afterwards kind of helped her case.

[jewelsonthepage]

Yeah, definitely. I like that scene better in the movie than the book. I love the way Kristen played that. The look on her face was like what a mistake she made, rather than, OMG I AM in love. How did I not know this before????

[peggababy]

I agree. All I saw when I watched Eclipse was that Bella just looked guilty for what she had just done, because really she just hurt Edward, and Edward saw it all in Jacob's mind. I agree with Robert Edward is just victimized in Eclipse.

[make_me_irish]

worst line in all three flims for me. IK. People go on about Edward making decisions for her but jeez.

Aww, thanks, Tam. As soon as I watched the commentary I've been wanting to do this but it took a while to get around to.

[jewelsonthepage]

But just as it is the worst line, it definitely encompasses the ass that Jacob is, and I'm so glad that Rob sees that too!

[make_me_irish]

yeah, this is why I can kinda deal with a lot of Jacob stuff because it just proves so well why I hate him.