FIC: "Riddle Me This" for xylodemon

Jun 12, 2006 12:26

Title: Riddle Me This
Author/Artist: ???
Recipient's name: xylodemon
Character: Minerva
Rating: G
Summary: By the time you have reached an informed decision it is too late to do anything anyway.
Warnings: (Mild) hetty subtext?
Notes: Thank you to M for beta-reading :-)

Riddle Me This )

mcgonagall, gen

Leave a comment

Comments 8

kethlenda June 12 2006, 19:27:13 UTC
Good job! I love the way you've shown the uncertainties and the worries behind Minerva's facade of cool detachment.

Reply


emei June 12 2006, 19:43:27 UTC
Well done! I really like Minerva's voice - she feels very real. Her relationship to Tom and to Hagrid was also very interesting.

Reply


stephanometra June 13 2006, 02:09:19 UTC
YAY MINERVA!FIC

The uncertain certainty running through this story is fantastic. J is a lucky, lucky girl.

Reply


waxrose June 13 2006, 04:26:59 UTC
Very well done - you've explored the uncertainties and fears behind the calm, detached mask of Minerva that we're familiar with and you did a splendid job. I really enjoyed reading this!

Reply


st_aurafina June 13 2006, 10:04:39 UTC
This was a lovely look at Minerva's thought processes through the COS crisis. It was also great to see some of her history, especially as a student.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up