I just realized I don't have answers to any of these. D:
DOBBY HELL YEAH
I'd say Kreacher is still in the Grimmauld Place-house. He's obviously very attached to it and now that he gets along with Harry then.. why would he go elsewhere?
What do you think happened to Kreacher after the war? Is he still with Harry?
I think after the war Kreacher was obviously happier. I don't think Harry would have kept him around, just because that's not the type of person that Harry is. Instead I think he probably just ordered him back to Hogwarts. I think Kreacher would have been happy there. There's plenty to do and lots of people he can serve. I think he probably died before Harry's kids got to the school, though. Just my opinion. I think if he were still around he would have been mentioned at some point in the epilogue. (Then again maybe not. Hagrid isn't mentioned.)
General opinion of themrandomnesesFebruary 12 2011, 00:46:16 UTC
The idea of House Elves make me really uncomfortable. I believe in self determination about stuff like "freeing yourself" from oppression, and I feel like while Hermione heart was in the right place, she didn't go about house elf liberation the right way. I'd like to think that there are some house elves that aren't totally brainwashed into servitude. Slavery doesn't really always work like that, contrary to popular belief.
Re: General opinion of themrandomnesesFebruary 12 2011, 00:55:57 UTC
I've got mixed feelings about this, because for some that may just be the brainwashing talking but at the same time it's condescending for some, like Hermione, to assume that they just didn't know any better and that they really do want to be free.
IDK IDK it's complicated but the idea of something that can think and speak and...all only living to serve others just is so D:
Comments 33
DOBBY HELL YEAH
I'd say Kreacher is still in the Grimmauld Place-house. He's obviously very attached to it and now that he gets along with Harry then.. why would he go elsewhere?
Reply
Reply
I think after the war Kreacher was obviously happier. I don't think Harry would have kept him around, just because that's not the type of person that Harry is. Instead I think he probably just ordered him back to Hogwarts. I think Kreacher would have been happy there. There's plenty to do and lots of people he can serve. I think he probably died before Harry's kids got to the school, though. Just my opinion. I think if he were still around he would have been mentioned at some point in the epilogue. (Then again maybe not. Hagrid isn't mentioned.)
Reply
No. She was loyal to her master just like any house elf would be
Maybe thought he could trust him with his secrets . Maybe he knew VOldemort would think lower of house elves and not see the abilites they have
I don't want to think about it
Dobby would get on Krecher's nerves. Dobby would try to get Krecher to seek money as well
Reply
Reply
I would do shots with her until I was ordering her to hold my hair back as I puke. Love that drunk ass house elf!
Reply
Why Winky over Kreacher and Dobby?
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
IDK IDK it's complicated but the idea of something that can think and speak and...all only living to serve others just is so D:
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment