Comments | hp_commonroom: Battle Headcanon

muchmoremacho in hp_commonroom

Battle Headcanon

Jun 28, 2011 19:10

( Read more... )

discussion

Leave a comment

Back to all threads

flyingpigs_live June 29 2011, 00:09:30 UTC

isn't it canon that the Slytherins joined Voldemort? i know JKR said they all came back to fight but Voldemort said to Lucius in DH that Draco didn't come and join him like the other Slytherins did. unless Jo meant something else, she lied about that.

gizmobunny June 29 2011, 00:15:01 UTC

I don't remember anything about the Slytherins joining Voldy, and I've read the book six times. Do you know what part of the book he said that?

flyingpigs_live June 29 2011, 02:37:56 UTC

it was in The Elder Wand chapter, page 641 (US version), in the shrieking shack when lucius is begging voldemort to let him go to the castle and draco. voldie says he did not come and join him, like the rest of the slytherins.

bitchet June 29 2011, 00:18:29 UTC

Who do you believe: JKR or Voldemort?

flyingpigs_live June 29 2011, 02:40:54 UTC

well, it's technically both, isn't it? considering JKR wrote it.

rainaweather June 30 2011, 02:15:54 UTC

Well Voldemort is a liar who lies to make himself look better, so I believe JKR.

maynardsong June 29 2011, 15:13:11 UTC

JKR said a lot of Slytherins came back, with Slughorn.

jesuslovesbono June 30 2011, 02:29:19 UTC

what i read is that JKR said the Slytherins went to get help.

Back to all threads