Cher (
hot4shoes): 35,126 comments (95.65%), played since 2005-12-22 (715 days at 49 comments/day)
Austin (
swingrrr): 1,599 comments (4.35%), played from 2006-12-31 to 2007-11-04 (308 days at 5 comments/day)
Total comment count: 36,725 since 2005-12-22 (714 days at 51 comments/day)