Lee, from Methos: A six pack and a bottle of very old Scotch with a note attatched. Yes, sick of it. Let's just keep drinking, they'll tire themselves out soon enough. -M
For Brienne : A silver pendant. There is no note attatched.
For Igor, from Raistlin: A box of powerful healing herbs and a book of dragon lore.
For Dean, from Sam: A six pack, a fresh pie and a note. Welcome back. -Sam
For Kurama, from Bobby: A new Yumi bow and quiver of charmed arrows.
For Eleventy, from Bobby: A large book on local demon lore, the page on kitsune is marked with a note. 'See? Not an alien.' (the grumbled 'idjit' is implied strongly enough)
((There are probably more I'm missing, but I can't quite figure out the right/clever gift or it's being done in an already ongoing thread))