Make me Choose
Jared Padalecki or Jensen Ackles? I love them both but for different reasons.
Dean or Sam? Dean
Season 1, 2, 3 or 4? Season 2
Meg or Ruby? Meg
Sam/Sarah or Sam/Jessica? Sam/Jessica
Bobby Singer or John Winchester? I love Bobby and I think he is a great father figure for the boys after John died. :)
John or Mary Winchester? John, he may not have always been around but he did care about his boys. :)
Yellow Eyed Demon or Lilith? Yellow Eyed Demon
Emo! Sam Or Emo! Dean? Emo! Sam
Harry Spengler or Ed Zeddmore? Ed Zeddmore
Shirtless Sam or Shirtless Dean? Shirtless Sam
Dressed as Priests or Dressed as Police Officers? Dressed as Police Officers
Cassie or Lisa with Dean? Cassie
Jo or Ellen Harvelle? Ellen Harvelle
Ava Wilson or Andy Gallagher? Andy Gallagher
Demon Sam or Demon Dean? Demon Sam
Season 3 Ruby or Season 4 Ruby? I loved season 3 Ruby and season 4 Ruby is not bad.
Ben (The Kids Are Alright) or Michael (Something Wicked)? Ben
Episodes:
Wendigo or Phantom Traveler? Phantom Traveler
Bloody Mary or Skin? Skin
Hookman or Home? Home
Asylum or Scarecrow? Scarecrow
Faith or Route 666? Route 666
Nightmare or The Benders? Nightmare
Hell House or Something Wicked? Something Wicked
Shadow or Provenance? Provenance
Dead Man's Blood or Devil's Trap? Devil's Trap
In My Time of Dying or Everybody Loves A Clown? In My Time Of Dying
Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things or Bloodlust? Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things
Simon Said or No Exit? Simon Said
The Usual Suspects or Crossroad Blues? The Usual Suspects
Croatoan or Hunted? Croatoan
Playthings or Nightshifter? Nightshifter
Houses of the Holy or Born Under A Bad Sign? Born Under A Bad Sign
Tall Tales or Roadkill? Tall Tales
Heart or Hollywood Babylon? Heart
Folsom Prison Blues or What Is And What Should Never Be? What Is And What Should Never Be
The Magnificent Seven or The Kids Are Alright? The Kids Are Alright
Bad Day At Black Rock or Sin City? Bad Day At Black Rock
Bedtime Stories or Red Sky At Morning? Bedtime Stories
Fresh Blood or A Very Supernatural Christmas? A Very Supernatural Christmas
Malleus Maleficarum or Dream A Little Dream of Me? Dream A Little Dream of Me
Mystery Spot or Jus A Bello? Mystery Spot
Ghostfacers or Long Distance Call? Long Distance Call
Time Is On Our Side or No Rest For The Wicked? No Rest for the Wicked
Lazarus Rising or Are You There God? It's Me, Dean Winchester? Lazarus Rising
In The Beginning or Metamorphosis? In The Beginning
Monster Movie or Yellow Fever? Yellow Fever
It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester or Wishful Thinking? It's The Great Pumpkin, Sam Winchester
I Know What You Did Last Summer or Heaven And Hell? I Know What You Did Last Summer
Family Remains or Chris Angel Is A Douche Bag? Christ Angel Is A Douche Bag
Future episodes that are coming up that I will pick on a later date.
After School Special or Sex And Violence?