The way he acted in the first day. His trains of logic. Something's not right there. Add to that the way you've been behaving all game, the fact that I know I'm not a wolf, and the fact that Shin didn't seem suspicious at all in the post I had with him.
oh man fail at voting AND at icons ...ah, my mistake.
I haven't spoken much with Shin, but he does seem to have been acting normally. I'll admit I wasn't watching him very carefully the first day, so I'm not sure what behavior you're referring to. However, his votes have been rather suspicious.
I suspected him for a good long while, so I made a post with him yesterday to feel him out. His reasoning, suggestions, and trains of thought all indicated that he was a sheep. At least, I doubt a wolf would continue on about things he was talking about.
Reread the first day. Note Rabi's attitude, particularly towards Nishi. Of the four of us, he's the only one where things don't quite add up. He made a few strange assumptions early on.
I just reread it and it seems that you're right. The way he votes and the things he says are strange, though I suppose he could be speaking to other people privately.
Mhh, that. Tomo told you, didn't she? When you guessed that she was the ram? The very first night, she protected herself, and the wolves tried to eat her, but failed. On the second night, the wolves had to get a hit in somehow. So, they went a target that she would not think of protecting. The more they miss, the more chances that we get to continue the game.
... I'm 95% positive that the wolf is Mizumachi, but I wanted to check.
Actually, no. The clues in particular don't point to anyone; they only single out a few people. Two sheep, one wolf, normally. That clue was two sheep, the ram, and one wolf. Tomo's the ram, we know that for sure.
She told me she hasn't been talking to anyone else, so it's unlikely she was told to do so. She likes Mizumachi, so I assume she was choosing randomly between Caesar and Tomo.
Unless she were a wolf. They discuss things in a post of their own.
... I trust you. My post with Mizumachi is here. He hasn't come across as being strange to me in the least, save for a couple of his comments in the ousting. Shin and I were talking around the same time you and I started talking, and I said this to him:
I still have to wonder about Mizumachi and Ahiru, but part of that is because nothing struck me as being off about Mizumachi. Whereas -- in the second day, Ahiru placed a vote on Tomo. She said as much, and didn't seem to have much of a reason to do so.
The wolves must have known by then that Tomo was the ram. Why else would she have been protected? That vote makes me think that Ahiru honestly had no idea what Tomo was, which means that she must be a sheep, which makes Mizumachi the wolf. But likewise, it could be a tactic to draw the ram out -- and to an extent, it worked, because Sena's argument clued Fakir and me off to who the ram was.... that last bit made me think, because of Mizumachi's response when posed
( ... )
..mm, that's a good point. I'm still not fully convinced, since she often does strange things and hasn't acted oddly otherwise, but it is something to consider. Perhaps it would be best to oust Rabi this round and hope the Shepherd decides to give us a more helpful clue the next round.
Reply
The way he acted in the first day. His trains of logic. Something's not right there. Add to that the way you've been behaving all game, the fact that I know I'm not a wolf, and the fact that Shin didn't seem suspicious at all in the post I had with him.
Reply
I haven't spoken much with Shin, but he does seem to have been acting normally. I'll admit I wasn't watching him very carefully the first day, so I'm not sure what behavior you're referring to. However, his votes have been rather suspicious.
Reply
I suspected him for a good long while, so I made a post with him yesterday to feel him out. His reasoning, suggestions, and trains of thought all indicated that he was a sheep. At least, I doubt a wolf would continue on about things he was talking about.
Reread the first day. Note Rabi's attitude, particularly towards Nishi. Of the four of us, he's the only one where things don't quite add up. He made a few strange assumptions early on.
Reply
Reply
... How has Ahiru been acting?
Reply
Very normally, for her. As you may have noticed, she is ill suited to this type of game, so I highly doubt she is a wolf.
Reply
... I'm 95% positive that the wolf is Mizumachi, but I wanted to check.
Reply
...all the evidence points that way, unless we misinterpreted the clue.
Reply
... Ahiru voting for Tomo that night bothers me.
Reply
She told me she hasn't been talking to anyone else, so it's unlikely she was told to do so. She likes Mizumachi, so I assume she was choosing randomly between Caesar and Tomo.
Reply
... I trust you. My post with Mizumachi is here. He hasn't come across as being strange to me in the least, save for a couple of his comments in the ousting. Shin and I were talking around the same time you and I started talking, and I said this to him:
I still have to wonder about Mizumachi and Ahiru, but part of that is because nothing struck me as being off about Mizumachi. Whereas -- in the second day, Ahiru placed a vote on Tomo. She said as much, and didn't seem to have much of a reason to do so.
The wolves must have known by then that Tomo was the ram. Why else would she have been protected? That vote makes me think that Ahiru honestly had no idea what Tomo was, which means that she must be a sheep, which makes Mizumachi the wolf. But likewise, it could be a tactic to draw the ram out -- and to an extent, it worked, because Sena's argument clued Fakir and me off to who the ram was.... that last bit made me think, because of Mizumachi's response when posed ( ... )
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment