Round 6; Challenge 3: Results

[quiddity_]

Bannermaker this week is hot_radcliffe. (Volunteer here!)

Eliminated:




elena_vlc_15
with -4 votes
iconlove90
with -3 votes
Sorry to see you go, but stick around for voting and the 2nd chance challenge!

People's Choice:Mod's Choice




orlandogirl
with +2 votes
azi_69_daniela

Comments:
#1: (-4) = -4
- the font used is a too plain and pixely
- The icon is not balanced. The black on the background competes with the red shading of the picture and the font is too harsh. Picture is blurred too.
- Too blurry
- harry and hermione are blury

#2: (-1) + (+3) = 2
- the icon is to contrasted
+ no comment
+ great cropping and the high contrast black/white fits the photo used very well
+ Good use of light and dark space

#3: (-4) + (+1) = -3
- it looks so blue down
- the cropping is a bit poorly done and the text/font does not fit the icon
- The font is difficult to read and the layout is unpleasant, particularly the colored part.
- The blended pictures do not complement each other. The glowing spots and the foggy effect do not seem to add anything to the composition.
+ no comment

#4: (-1) + (+1) = 0
- Too blurry, coloring is very brownish, and the side texture doesn't compliment the image
+ no comment

#5: (-1) = -1
- The transition between the two pictures is choppy/too fast

#6: (-1) + (+1) = 0
- texture doesn't look icon and coloring is too orange
+ The picture is a little blurred but the coloring and the cropping are the best.

THE NEXT CHALLENGE HAS BEEN POSTED.