Eek! So I posted that trivia FOREVER ago and never followed up with the answers! I am so sorry! I got distracted and then totally forgot about it!
I went through and I think
funnybones021 was the closest to being spot on. Though
seraphimkiss and
8nnemiek were both super close.
8nnemiek it was Big Gino that was the loan shark (though you could probably make an argument that Torvald is one too) and
seraphimkiss it's Dino Spumoni and Don Reynolds!
So under here are all the answers, pulled word-for-word from the trivia cards. Typos and all. The little bits next to the asterisks and in parentheses are my own interruptions and corrections, because Nick botched some of the questions/answers.
1) Fourth
2) Ruth (*Also: Summer, Miss Felter, Lila, Maria. It probably would have been better to go with Lila because he seemed to like her for more seasons.)
3) Mr. Warz (* I’m almost positive that Wartz should have a ‘T’ in his name.)
4) Mr. Wittenburg (*Coach!)
5) A butcher
6) Dino and Don Spumoni (*It’s actually Don Reynolds and Dino Spumoni. They aren’t brothers!)
7) Iggy (* Though Arnold also wore them later in the episode!)
8) Big Gino
9) Four
10) Ya-hoo Soda
11) Agitha Cawfield (*It should probably be Agatha Caulfield)
12) Abner
13) A banana and a strawberry
14) An old tortoise
15) Japanese
16) Helga’s fists
17) She got hit by a car
18) The oldest tree in the neighborhood (*and it’s MIGHTY Pete)
19) Gerald M. Johannsen
20) Olga
21) Her closet (*it was maybe in the attic above her closet in the movie though)
22) Mr. Green
23) Pookie (*Her REAL name is Gertie, BTW)
24) Grandma
25) Stinky (*Only for the first (two?) season(s).)
26) 33
27) Miss Felter
28) Curly
29) Blue
30) A freeway
31) You Can’t Do That on Television
32) The Big Ballot
33) 1991
34) Pinwheel
35) Doug, Rugrats, and Ren & Stimpy
ETA: You can find the questions
HERE.