These reviews, always imaginative and opinionated, are now becoming just plain silly.
Judge for yourself ( for those unfamiliar with the Society's numbering system, they are Glencadam and Longmorn in that order):
https://www.smws.co.uk/shop/whisky/product.php?id_bottlings=2983&utm_source=August%20Outturn%20Preview&utm_medium=email&utm_content=August%20Outturn%20Preview