Killjoys + Snowflake Challenge, days 2-5
An assortment of fannish things!
1) fandom_stocking extended its deadline to Wed, 1/11. I am usually impatient to see all the goodies revealed, but this year I'm greatly relieved, because between the stockings going up pretty late, crazy work, holiday, and feeling sick, I haven't actually managed to do anything yet, beyond browse and take notes, ( Read more... )
1) fandom_stocking extended its deadline to Wed, 1/11. I am usually impatient to see all the goodies revealed, but this year I'm greatly relieved, because between the stockings going up pretty late, crazy work, holiday, and feeling sick, I haven't actually managed to do anything yet, beyond browse and take notes, ( Read more... )
Maybe I would've actually enjoyed reading Neverending Story if I had met it before the movie, but the movie was so WTF-y to me, I never tried to pick up the book.
I think the problem is that it's a different "kind" of story - more focused, told within a smaller space, if that makes sense?
It does, and I think you're probably right. The characters in Justice weren't what hooked me, it was the worldbuilding and the pronoun gimmick that actually worked, and I expect Sword, as you describe it, probably won't hook me as much. But I definitely want to continue with the series.
Tigana is one of those books that some people really love and others... really don't. But I could also see it being a book that one could like when younger and outgrow -- it's kind of Return of the King played mostly straight, and I just don't have patience for that anymore.
Sailing to Sarantium was I think the first GGK book I ever read, so my memories of it are positive and numinous, but probably artificially so, if you know what I mean. And as for The Summer Tree and the rest of the Fionavar books, ahaha. I really, really loved Diarmuid, and liked a few other characters, but on the whole it's just such a weird book! Like, I want to pat GGK on the head because it is perfectly natural to be so overwhelmed by Tolkien's writing that you want to grow up to be Just Like Him, but on the other hand, he did so much better when he branched out and did his historical fantasy instead. And there's random Arthuriana, which, like, why?
Reply
Well, no guarantees, but my child self at least really liked it. XD And IIRC it did a better job of explaining things / having a logical progress of events than the movie did (and a better ending, too), though IIRC it was still somewhat surreal.
it was the worldbuilding and the pronoun gimmick that actually worked
Yeah, somewhat the same here - I enjoyed the characters, but none of them really became mine.
The pronoun gimmick definitely continues to be a thing, it's just not new anymore. And IMO, she continues worldbuilding in interesting ways, just on a smaller scale.
Anyway, either way I look forward to hearing what you think of it. :)
my memories of it are positive and numinous, but probably artificially so, if you know what I mean.
Ahahaha, yeah. There's a reason there are some authors that I just ... don't re-read. XD
Like, I want to pat GGK on the head because it is perfectly natural to be so overwhelmed by Tolkien's writing that you want to grow up to be Just Like Him,
pfffft. :D You know, it hadn't occurred to me to make that connection (probably due to my much weaker connection to LotR :D), but ... I could see it.
But, I mean, who wouldn't want to be a character in a portal fantasy to an LotR/Arthuriana mashup???? :D
Reply
Yeah, that's what I meant, too.
As far as GGK, the connection to Tolkien's writing is actually more explicit -- as a young man, he helped Christopher Tolkien edit The Silmarillion. His first book was published quite a bit later (according to Wiki, he started working on The Sil in 1974, Sil's publication date is 1977, and GGK's first book came out in 1984) -- but I'm pretty sure there was a Tolkien overdose involved :P
But, I mean, who wouldn't want to be a character in a portal fantasy to an LotR/Arthuriana mashup???? :D
It's kind of adorable, because he is clearly cramming in ALL his favorite fantasy things, whether they make any sense together or not. I've been there, Guy Gavriel Kay! I feel you, buddy!
Reply
Leave a comment